Robbing is the moment an apiary turns from calm to chaotic. Bees from one colony, or from several, strip honey from another, and the fight at the entrance can kill the victim within a day or two. It spreads disease, spurs stinging, and can start from something as small as a spilled drop of syrup. The good news is that robbing is predictable. It is driven by a shortage of nectar, and you can prevent most of it by managing entrances, feeding and your own inspection habits. This article covers causes, how to tell robbing from normal activity, prevention, and an emergency response.
Why robbing starts
Robbing happens when natural nectar is scarce, usually in late summer or during a dearth, and when an easy source of sugar is available. Bees that cannot find nectar in the field start investigating other sources, including weak colonies, open honey, extractors, and spilled syrup. Once foragers learn that a particular hive or spill yields reward, they recruit others.
Several triggers can start the process:
- Opening a hive during a dearth and leaving honey exposed.
- Leaving wet supers outdoors after extraction.
- Spilled or dripping syrup from feeders.
- A weak, queenless, or small colony with a large entrance.
- Cracks in boxes that allow scent to escape.
The most vulnerable colonies are those with few guards relative to the space they hold. A strong colony usually defends itself. A nuc, a newly installed package, or a colony weakened by Varroa is easy prey. See Small Hive Beetle (SHB): Identification and Control for another pest that follows weak colonies.
Telling robbing from orientation flights
Beginners often confuse robbing with the lively but harmless activity of young bees. Orientation flights occur in the afternoon of a warm day, when young bees hover in front of the hive facing the entrance, bobbing in and out of sight. They look relaxed and do not fight.
Robbing looks tense. Bees dart quickly, approach seams and cracks rather than the entrance, and fly in zigzag patterns around the hive. Guards grapple with intruders, and you may see bees wrestling and falling to the ground. Robbers leave the hive with their abdomens full and fly straight up and away, and they approach the hive from a downward angle, while bees returning with pollen or nectar come in straight.
A good test is to watch the entrance for a few minutes. If there is a lot of fighting, bees falling together, and bees with shiny, hairless bodies, it is robbing. Wasps entering the hive are a related problem; see Yellowjackets: Fall Robbing Pressure.
Preventing robbing
Prevention is much easier than cure. Think of it as a set of habits.
- Reduce entrances in late summer, especially on weak colonies. A smaller opening is easier to guard.
- Keep colonies strong. Combine weak ones. See Combining Weak Colonies: Newspaper Method.
- Feed carefully. Use in-hive feeders, feed in the evening, and clean up spills. See Entrance Feeders vs. In-Hive Feeders.
- Work quickly in a dearth. Open hives for short periods, do not leave frames exposed, and close up promptly.
- Avoid extracting outdoors. Extract indoors or in a bee-proof space, and do not leave wet supers out.
- Close cracks and holes in boxes, and keep equipment in good repair.
Install robbing screens before the problem begins. They are inexpensive and effective. See Robbing Screens: Installation and Use and Mouse Guards and Entrance Reducers.
Emergency response
If you see robbing in progress, act quickly.
- Reduce the entrance to a very small opening immediately, or close it temporarily with a screen that allows ventilation.
- Cover the hive with a damp sheet or cloth, wetting the cloth so that robbers are confused. Leave an opening for the bees to enter and leave, and for ventilation.
- Stop all work in the yard. Close all hives, and do not open any until the situation calms.
- Remove sources of attraction, such as exposed honey and spilled syrup.
- Install a robbing screen if you have one.
If the colony is badly weakened, you may need to move it to a new location at least a few miles away, or combine it with a strong colony. Do not leave a ruined colony in place, because robbers will continue. After the flurry, check the queen, brood, and stores.
Never use sprays or unlabeled products to stop robbers. Overheating a hive with a cloth cover in hot weather can harm the colony, so keep ventilation and check often.
Robbing and disease
Robbing is a major route for disease spread. Robber bees carry honey and pathogens from a weak or dead colony to healthy ones. American foulbrood spores can be carried this way. If you suspect that a colony was killed by disease, seal it up, and do not leave it open where bees can rob.
This is why a dead-out should be handled carefully. A colony that died of foulbrood and was robbed out can spread spores to many colonies. If you are unsure of the cause, close up the equipment and consider testing. See American Foulbrood (AFB): Identification and Response and Foulbrood Spore Detection: Testing Options.
Robbing also spreads mites and viruses. A collapsing Varroa-infested colony, whose bees are robbed by neighbors, can spread mites to healthy colonies, a process sometimes called mite bombs. See Varroa Destructor: The Beekeeper's Primary Enemy for the mite side. Keep records of robbing events, and watch for disease in nearby hives in the following weeks.
Robbing during extraction and in the honey house
Honey houses and extraction rooms are robbing hotspots. The smell of honey carries, and bees will find any gap. Seal the room, covering windows with screens, and work with doors closed. Do not leave supers outside, even if they seem empty, since wet frames still contain honey.
Return wet supers to the hives after extraction in the evening, so that bees clean them without a mass robbing event. Use the same hive that the supers came from, or place them above an inner cover in a way that distributes them. Avoid dumping wet supers in an open pile.
If you extract away from the apiary, keep the location in mind. A pile of wet supers near hives can start a robbing frenzy. See Manual vs. Electric Extractors for equipment, and plan your harvest to occur during a flow, when bees are less interested in robbing.
Seasonal calendar
Robbing pressure follows the flow.
| Time | Risk | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Spring buildup | Low, but nucs and splits are vulnerable | Small entrances for small colonies |
| Main flow | Low | Normal management |
| Late summer dearth | High | Reduce entrances, install screens |
| Fall | High | Careful feeding, wasp control |
| Winter | Low | Check for mouse guards and ventilation |
Use the calendar to prepare. For fall tasks, see Fall Inspections: What to Check. Keep a note in your records about the first sign of robbing each year. It tells you when the local flow ends and helps you schedule extraction, feeding and entrance reduction in the following season.
FAQ
How can I tell robbing from orientation flights?
Orientation flights are relaxed hovering in front of the hive in the afternoon. Robbing involves fighting at the entrance, zigzag flight along seams and cracks, and bees falling together.
What is the first thing to do when I see robbing?
Reduce the entrance to a tiny opening, stop opening hives, and remove any exposed honey or syrup. Add a robbing screen if you have one, and consider combining a weak colony.
Does robbing spread disease?
Yes. Robbers carry honey and pathogens, including foulbrood spores and mites, from weak or dead colonies to healthy ones, so closing up suspect equipment is important.