Combining two colonies into one is among the most useful rescue tools in the apiary, and the newspaper method is the most reliable way to do it. A weak colony that cannot defend itself, build up or make honey can be united with a stronger neighbour, producing a single hive that has a good chance of surviving winter or producing a crop. Done carelessly, combining leads to fighting and dead bees. Done properly, it is smooth and nearly invisible to the bees. This article explains when to combine, how to use the newspaper method, and how to avoid common mistakes.
Why combine
The reasons are practical. A small colony in fall is unlikely to survive winter, while a combined colony can cluster and keep warm. A queenless colony in spring or summer will dwindle and may develop laying workers, and combining it with a queenright colony saves its bees. A weak colony in a honey flow adds little, so merging it with a strong colony increases the foraging force.
Combining is also a sensible response to disease or pest concerns, but be careful: never combine a colony with suspected foulbrood or heavy mite infestation without addressing the problem first. Check for disease and treat as necessary. If in doubt, consult your apiary inspector. See Managing Strong vs. Weak Colonies for how to decide which colonies to keep.
Which colony keeps its queen
Choose the better queen. If one colony is queenless, it is simple: unite the queenless colony with the queenright one. If both have queens, decide which queen to keep, based on brood pattern, age and temperament. You can remove the poorer queen a day or two before combining, so that the colony knows it is queenless and accepts the other's bees more readily. Do not try to keep both queens.
If you plan to requeen, combine the colonies and then introduce a new queen to the united colony once the merge is complete; see Queen Introduction: Direct vs. Cage Methods. Remember that a colony needs about 24 hours without a queen to be receptive to a new one. In general, place the weaker colony on top of the stronger.
The newspaper method step by step
The newspaper method works because the bees need time to chew through the paper, during which they acclimatise to one another's odour so that when they meet, they do not fight.
- Choose a calm day and work in the late afternoon or when foragers are home.
- Remove the queen from the colony being given up, or confirm that it is queenless.
- Remove the lid and inner cover of the stronger (bottom) colony.
- Place a single sheet of ordinary newspaper over the top bars of the bottom box, smoothed flat.
- Cut a few small slits, about an inch long, in the paper with the hive tool. Avoid large holes.
- Set the top box from the weaker colony on top of the paper, making sure all the frames sit properly.
- Replace the inner cover and lid. If the top box has a separate bottom board, remove it.
- Leave it alone for about a week. Bees will chew through the paper and mingle.
- After a week, check, remove paper remnants, and arrange the brood and honey into a compact nest.
Use plain newsprint, not glossy or coloured paper. Do not use too many slits, which allows bees to mix too quickly.
Sorting the combined colony
After the colonies merge, consolidate frames. Put brood frames in the lower box, honey above, and remove empty frames. If space is too big for the combined bee population, reduce the boxes by removing the spare. Keep honey close to the cluster. In fall, ensure that the combined colony has enough stores; feed if needed, as described in Fall Feeding: 2:1 Syrup and Fondant.
Where the combined colony is large, you may want to leave both boxes as they are, with brood in both and the queen laying in the lower. After a few weeks, check that the queen is laying and that both boxes are active. In spring, the merged colony may be an ideal candidate for supers if the flow is coming; see Adding Supers: Timing and Configuration.
Timing and preparation
The best time to combine is when the decision is clear. In spring, combine before the main flow so the merged colony can use it. In summer, combine weak colonies and queenless ones as soon as you identify them, to avoid laying workers. In fall, combine in September while bees are still active and can chew through the paper, and give the merged colony time to settle and be fed before cold weather.
Prepare by gathering your materials ahead of time: newspaper, a hive tool, a spare inner cover and a feeder if needed. If the colonies are in different yards, move the weaker one to the stronger one's yard a day or two earlier, keeping them a few feet apart, so foragers have reoriented. Reduce the entrance on the merged hive to help it defend itself, and check back in a week.
Special cases
Queenless colony with laying workers. Laying workers can resist combining, and their bees may attack a queen. The usual recommendation is to shake out the laying worker colony some distance from the hive, so workers return to nearby hives, or to combine with newspaper after removing the box from its stand; see Laying Workers: When the Queen Is Gone. Do not introduce a queen directly into a laying-worker colony.
Combining in late fall. Be careful, because bees clustering in cold weather will not chew paper quickly. Combine early in fall, when it is still warm, rather than waiting for cold.
Combining with different strains. Mixing different races or lines can cause temperament differences, but the bees usually adjust. Make sure that the stronger queen remains.
Mistakes to avoid
Common mistakes include using too large holes in the newspaper, which lets bees mingle too fast and causes fighting. Another is combining a diseased colony with a healthy one. A third is combining without checking for the queen, ending up with two queens fighting. A fourth is failing to reduce space afterward.
Another error is doing it at the wrong time. Combining during a strong flow can work, but robbing may complicate matters in a dearth. If you combine at a time when robbing is likely, reduce entrances and avoid spills. Always work calmly, with minimal smoke. Keep records of the date and which colonies you combined, because it will help you track performance. For splits and the reverse process, see Making Splits: Techniques and Timing.
FAQ
How long does the newspaper method take?
Bees usually chew through the paper within a day or two, and by a week the colonies have merged. Leave the hive alone during this time.
Do I have to find the queen of the weaker colony?
Yes, ideally. Remove the poorer queen before combining, or confirm that the colony is queenless, so that only one queen remains.
Can I combine colonies in winter?
It is not recommended. Bees in cold weather will not chew paper effectively and disturbing the cluster is risky. Combine in early fall or in spring.