American foulbrood, or AFB, is the most serious bacterial disease of honey bee brood. It is caused by Paenibacillus larvae, a spore-forming bacterium that kills larvae and can survive for decades as spores. AFB spreads easily between colonies and apiaries, and in most places it is a reportable or regulated disease, so a suspected case calls for contacting your state apiary inspector. This article explains how to recognize AFB, how it differs from other brood problems, what to do on suspicion, and how to prevent its spread. As an inspector, I treat every suspect frame as a serious matter until it has been tested.
What AFB Is
Paenibacillus larvae produces spores that bees feed to young larvae in contaminated food. Spores germinate in the larval gut, the bacteria multiply, and the larva dies after its cell is capped. The dead larva decomposes into a sticky, brown mass. Billions of spores form in each dead larva. Nurse bees clean out dead larvae and spread spores throughout the colony.
Spores are extremely durable. They resist heat, cold, drying and many disinfectants. Contaminated honey, wax and equipment can carry spores for many years. A colony can have spores without disease, but when enough spores are present, clinical disease follows.
AFB spreads through robbing, drifting, swarms, shared equipment, and the movement of infected comb, honey or colonies. Beekeepers can also spread it unknowingly by feeding honey of unknown origin. For this reason, local regulations often restrict movement of bees and equipment.
Signs to Look For
No single sign is perfect, and a combination is more convincing. Look for:
- Spotty or "pepper-pot" brood pattern. Capped cells interspersed with empty ones, because dead brood is removed or cells remain unsealed. See Recognizing a Healthy Brood Pattern
- Sunken, darkened, greasy cappings. Cappings may be concave, dark brown and moist-looking
- Perforated cappings. Small holes chewed by bees trying to clean out the cells
- Ropiness. The classic matchstick test: insert a matchstick or twig into a suspect cell, stir, and withdraw slowly. If the dead larva stretches out in a brown thread of an inch or more before snapping back, it indicates AFB
- Scale. A hard, dark scale lies flat on the lower cell wall and is difficult to remove. It may be viewed with light from the right angle
- Odor. A foul smell, often compared with rotting glue or fish, may be noticeable in advanced cases
Use gloves or a clean stick, and clean your hive tool afterward. Do not rub your hands on equipment or other hives. The matchstick test is a useful field indicator, but it is not a definitive diagnosis.
Look-Alikes
Other conditions resemble AFB and can confuse beekeepers.
| Condition | Key differences |
|---|---|
| European Foulbrood (EFB): Stress-Related Disease | Affects uncapped or recently capped larvae; larvae twisted, melted; not typically ropy; sour smell |
| Chalkbrood: Fungal Infection Management | Hard white or gray mummies, not slime |
| Sacbrood Virus: Identification and Impact | Larvae form a fluid-filled sac with a pointed head |
| Chilled or starved brood | Dead larvae across a wide area, no ropiness |
| Pesticide kill | Dead brood and adults near the entrance; see Pesticide Exposure: Recognizing and Responding |
| Varroa damage | Mites and virus signs; see Varroa Destructor: The Beekeeper's Primary Enemy |
Do not guess. If you see anything that resembles AFB, take it seriously. A positive ropiness test means that you should stop and call for confirmation. Lateral-flow test kits are available to beekeepers and give a quick indication, but they can give false positives or negatives, and official diagnosis requires a lab.
What to Do if You Suspect AFB
Act methodically. The goal is confirmation and containment.
- Stop the inspection if you are in a vulnerable situation. Close the hive carefully to avoid attracting robbers.
- Do not move frames, honey, or equipment from the suspect hive to others.
- Reduce the entrance to prevent robbing. See Robbing Screens: Installation and Use
- Contact your state apiarist or apiary inspector. Many states offer free testing and will advise on regulations.
- Collect a sample as instructed. Typically a piece of comb with suspect brood about the size of your palm is mailed in a paper bag or cardboard, not plastic, as the lab directs.
- Clean your tools and gloves. Change clothes before visiting other apiaries
- Avoid visiting other apiaries until you know the result
If confirmed, follow your state's requirements. Do not decide on your own how to dispose of the colony before checking local rules, as regulations may require specific methods. See AFB Eradication: Burning and Irradiation for the options.
Reporting and Regulations
In many states and countries, AFB is a reportable disease, and inspectors have authority to order treatment or destruction of infected colonies. Rules vary, so check with your state apiarist. In the U.S., you can also find information through USDA APHIS and the state-by-state directory.
Inspectors can be allies, not enemies. They have experience, they can test, and they help protect the whole beekeeping community. Beekeepers who hide AFB put every colony around them at risk.
If you buy used equipment, nucs or colonies, ask about their disease history and, where possible, ask for an inspection certificate. Inspect brood on arrival. Never buy comb or equipment of unknown origin without caution.
Prevention
There is no way to eliminate spores from the environment, but you can reduce risk.
- Inspect brood at least a few times a season. See Learning to Inspect a Hive: A Youth's Guide
- Keep strong colonies, since strong bees clean out diseased brood better
- Avoid feeding honey of unknown origin
- Use hygienic stock. See Hygienic Behavior: The Genetic Basis
- Reduce robbing; keep entrances reduced when forage is scarce
- Keep tools clean; see Apiary Hygiene: Equipment Cleaning and Disinfection
- Avoid swapping frames among colonies without inspection
- Replace old comb on a rotation. See Comb Rotation: Why and When
- Know the source of your bees and equipment
- Maintain records; see Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs
- Use the testing services of the state apiary program
A beekeeper who knows what a healthy brood pattern looks like will notice AFB sooner. Practice with your mentor or inspector, and use the matchstick test on a few healthy cells as a baseline.
Antibiotics and Why They Do Not Solve AFB
In some places, antibiotics approved for use in honey bees may be allowed under veterinary oversight, but they only suppress clinical signs and do not kill spores. Using them can hide the disease while spores accumulate in the hive, so the colony stays infectious. This is a reason why many jurisdictions require destruction of infected colonies rather than treatment.
Regulations differ regarding prophylactic and therapeutic use. In the U.S., antibiotic use requires veterinary involvement and must follow the label. I will not give doses or procedures here. Never use antibiotics as a routine preventive measure, and never feed them without veterinary direction. Resistance in AFB bacteria has been documented, and residues in honey are a concern.
For details on options, ask your state apiarist or a veterinarian experienced with bees. See also Foulbrood Spore Detection: Testing Options for spore testing.
Common Mistakes
- Dismissing a suspicious frame as "just chilled brood"
- Carrying a diseased frame to show a friend
- Leaving an open hive where robbers can reach it
- Trying to treat with home remedies
- Not contacting the inspector
- Reusing equipment from an AFB colony without proper sterilization
- Feeding imported honey
- Moving suspect colonies
- Waiting to see if it clears up
- Assuming one infected hive is not a risk to others
FAQ
How do I tell AFB from other brood diseases?
The ropiness test, sunken greasy cappings, scale and odor point to AFB, but only laboratory testing or an inspector's confirmation is definitive.
Do I have to report AFB?
In most places it is reportable or regulated, so contact your state apiarist or inspector, who can test and advise on the rules.
Can AFB be cured with antibiotics?
Antibiotics only suppress signs and do not kill spores, so many jurisdictions require destruction of infected colonies, and any drug use needs veterinary direction and a label.