Feeders fall into two families: those that sit at the entrance, such as the Boardman, and those that sit inside the hive, such as top, frame and pail feeders. The choice affects robbing, bee safety, cold-weather feeding, how often you must open the hive and how much syrup you can offer at once. This article compares the two families, explains the trade-offs, and gives a practical decision guide. In short: in-hive feeders win for most situations, but entrance feeders have a few valid uses.
The basic difference
An entrance feeder sits at the front of the hive, usually a jar or a trough on the entrance reducer. Bees come to it from inside or outside the hive. An in-hive feeder is inside the hive body or on top of it, sheltered by the box and the cover. Bees reach it from inside only.
That difference sets the main trade-offs: exposure and robbing, ease of monitoring, temperature and capacity. Understanding them lets you choose the right tool for the colony and the season. For a catalogue of feeder types, see Feeding Equipment: Boardman, Top, and Frame Feeders.
Entrance feeders: what they do well
Entrance feeders are common and cheap. They are best for:
- Small colonies or nucs that cannot use a large volume.
- Quick monitoring. You can see the syrup level without opening the hive.
- Medicated or measured feeding when you want to meter small amounts, following a label.
- Colonies in warm weather with no robbing pressure.
They are convenient for beginners because they do not require opening the hive to refill. The jar can be changed quickly, and you can see whether bees are taking food.
Entrance feeders: what goes wrong
- Robbing. Syrup at the entrance announces food to every bee and wasp in the area. In a dearth, an entrance feeder can start robbing quickly; see Robbing Behavior: Prevention and Response.
- Cold weather. Bees must leave the cluster to reach the feeder, so in cool conditions they may not feed, and the syrup may chill.
- Small capacity. A quart does not go far for a growing colony.
- Leaks. Poor seals can leak, soaking the entrance and attracting ants.
- Drowning. Bees can fall into the jar if the feeder is poorly designed.
Many beekeepers who started with entrance feeders switch to in-hive models after a season of robbing or messy leaks.
In-hive feeders: what they do well
In-hive feeders, including top, frame and pail feeders, share several benefits:
- Protection from robbers. The syrup is inside the hive.
- Warmth. Bees feed in the cluster's microclimate.
- Capacity. Gallons rather than quarts.
- Fewer disturbances to flight. Bees do not crowd the entrance.
They suit larger colonies, fall feeding, and cooler weather. See Bucket Feeders and Pail Feeders for a closer look at one popular design.
In-hive feeders: the downsides
- You must open the hive to refill or check, which disturbs the colony.
- Drowning risk if the feeder has no floats or ladders.
- Extra equipment, such as an extra box to cover a top feeder.
- Mould and fermentation if syrup sits too long.
- Space. A frame feeder takes the place of a frame.
- Hard to monitor, since you cannot see the level easily without opening.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Entrance feeder | In-hive feeder |
|---|---|---|
| Robbing risk | Higher | Lower |
| Capacity | Small | Large |
| Cold-weather use | Poor | Good |
| Monitoring | Easy | Requires opening |
| Disturbance on refill | Low | Moderate |
| Cost | Low | Low to moderate |
| Best for | Nucs, warm weather, small colonies | Most colonies, fall feeding |
A decision guide
- Is it cold? Use an in-hive feeder over or beside the cluster.
- Is there a dearth with robbing pressure? Use in-hive, with reduced entrances and a screen if needed; see Robbing Screens: Installation and Use.
- Is the colony small or a nuc? An entrance feeder or a small frame feeder is fine in warm weather.
- Do you need a lot of syrup quickly? Use a top or pail feeder.
- Do you want to avoid opening the hive? Use an entrance feeder, or a pail or top feeder with a window.
- Is it winter? Do not use liquid; use fondant or candy boards; see Fondant and Candy Boards.
Feeding practices that matter more than the feeder
The feeder is only part of good feeding. Good practices:
- Feed at dusk to reduce robbing and foraging confusion.
- Use clean, plain sugar. No brown sugar or honey of unknown source.
- Avoid feeding with supers on.
- Match the ratio to the season. Thinner syrup in spring; thicker in fall.
- Watch the colony. If bees ignore the feeder, ask why: cold, queenlessness, or enough natural nectar.
- Check for leaks and spills and clean them up.
For when and why to feed, see Spring Feeding: Syrup Ratios and Methods and Fall Feeding: 2:1 Syrup and Fondant.
Recommendations
For most beginners with a single hive, an in-hive feeder, either a top feeder or a frame feeder, is the best purchase. Add an entrance feeder only if you have small colonies in mild weather, or if you want a quick indicator. For many colonies, a pail feeder is the most economical. Whatever you choose, be consistent, clean the equipment, and watch your bees. Read more in Feeding Bees: 4-H Project Responsibilities.
Seasonal and regional notes
Spring. Colonies are expanding and may take syrup readily, but cold nights make entrance feeders unreliable. An in-hive feeder over the cluster keeps syrup accessible. See Spring Feeding: Syrup Ratios and Methods.
Summer dearth. Robbing risk is at its highest, so avoid anything at the entrance, reduce entrances, and feed only at dusk if you must feed at all.
Fall. Colonies need to store syrup quickly while it is warm. Large-capacity in-hive feeders do this best; entrance feeders cannot keep pace.
Hot, humid regions. Syrup spoils quickly, and ants, wasps and small hive beetles are attracted to spills. Smaller amounts, frequent changes and tidy feeders matter more than the type of feeder.
Cold regions. Liquid feeding ends when nights drop near freezing. Plan fall feeding early enough to finish before then.
Regional keeper clubs are a great source of timing advice, since flows, pests and weather vary widely.
FAQ
Why do entrance feeders cause robbing?
The syrup is exposed at the hive entrance, so robbers from other colonies and wasps can find it easily, especially during a dearth.
Can bees feed from an in-hive feeder in cold weather?
Yes, if it sits directly above or beside the cluster, because bees can take syrup without leaving the warmth of the cluster, though liquid feed is not suited to freezing temperatures.
Which feeder is best for a nuc?
A small frame feeder or an entrance feeder works well in mild weather, since a nuc cannot take much syrup at a time.