Woodpeckers can punch fist-sized holes in the sides of a hive, mostly in winter, to eat the bees inside. Other birds, from kingbirds to bee-eaters, take bees in flight during the season. Most of this predation is minor and local, but a persistent woodpecker can destroy a colony's insulation and expose the cluster to cold and moisture. This article explains which birds eat bees, how to recognize their damage, what protects hives, and how to respond legally and humanely, since many birds are protected by law.
Which birds eat bees
Several kinds of birds eat honey bees. Flycatchers such as kingbirds and phoebes catch bees at flowers and near the hive. Bee-eaters in parts of Europe, Africa and Asia specialize on stinging insects. Martins, swallows, and some other species also take bees from the air. Woodpeckers, particularly flickers and pileated woodpeckers, are the species that cause the structural damage beekeepers worry about.
Woodpeckers eat insects, and in winter they drum on hive walls to find the cluster and extract bees. A hive is a warm, buzzing target, and a woodpecker can hear the cluster. They tend to attack hives in winter, when natural insect prey is scarce, and damage often occurs near the cluster where the buzzing is loudest.
Most bird predation of foragers is minor and not worth acting on. A colony that is strong can absorb a few lost bees a day. The problem arises when birds target the hive itself.
Recognizing woodpecker damage
Look for holes in the sides of boxes, often at about the level of the cluster, with ragged edges. Holes may be several inches wide. Wood chips on the ground or on the landing board and a hollowed-out appearance in the box are common. Bees may be exposed through the hole, and comb may be torn.
Signs can also include repeated tapping sounds heard during the day. A pileated woodpecker can create large rectangular holes, while smaller species make round holes.
Differentiate from other damage such as mouse chewing at the entrance or squirrel damage. Woodpecker holes are generally higher on the box, not at the base. Check the interior for exposed comb and dead bees. A hole in winter can let in cold air and moisture, which is a serious threat to the colony. Quick action matters. See Winter Cluster Dynamics: Heat Generation and Survival for why a cluster is vulnerable to drafts and moisture.
Preventive wraps and barriers
The most effective prevention is physical. Wrap the hive in a way that stops the woodpecker from reaching the wood or from hearing the cluster.
Options include:
- Hardware cloth wrap. Cover the sides of boxes with wire mesh, leaving a small gap between the mesh and the wood so that the bird cannot grab it. Quarter-inch to half-inch mesh is common.
- Insulating wraps. Winter wraps or tar paper reduce noise and heat and make boxes less attractive. See Winter Covers and Insulation Kits.
- Foam board or burlap. Some beekeepers use an outer layer that dampens sound, though they must keep ventilation and entrance clear.
- Netting. Bird netting loosely hung around the hive can discourage woodpeckers, but it can trap birds, so use with care and check often.
Install wraps in late fall, before woodpecker pressure begins. Make sure any wrap leaves the entrance and upper ventilation clear. For general winter preparation, see Preparing Your Hive for Winter: First-Year Edition.
Deterrents and their limits
Visual and noise deterrents are used, such as reflective tape, hanging shiny objects, plastic owls or hawks, and noise makers. Results are mixed. Birds habituate quickly, and these methods rarely work for long. They are most useful as short-term measures while you install a physical barrier.
Do not use sticky substances or poison. These can harm birds and are illegal in many places. Do not shoot birds. Woodpeckers and many other species are protected under law in the United States and elsewhere, and killing or harming them can carry fines. Check with your state wildlife agency before taking any action on a protected species, and see the state-by-state directory for state contacts.
Providing alternative food, such as suet feeders, placed away from the apiary, may draw woodpeckers away in winter. Results vary, and a feeder can also attract more birds.
Repair and response
When a woodpecker has made a hole, repair it promptly, preferably on a mild day when bees can be handled safely. Patch the hole from the outside with a piece of wood or metal flashing screwed over it, or with a secure patch. If the damage is extensive, replace the box when you can do so without chilling the cluster. Do not open a hive in cold weather unless necessary.
If comb is exposed and bees are dying in the cold, it may be better to apply a temporary patch, such as a board or insulating material, and then fix it later. Add the wrap to prevent a repeat. Check the colony's stores and cluster size, and provide emergency feed if needed. See Emergency Winter Feeding: Candy Boards and Mountain Camp for options.
Record the date and details, and tell neighboring beekeepers, since a woodpecker can range over several yards and may revisit.
Bird predation in the active season
Summer bird predation is a different matter from winter drilling. Kingbirds and phoebes perch near an apiary and snap up foragers returning with loads, and they favor drones, which are large and slow. Swallows and martins feed on bees in the air over open fields. A strong colony loses a tiny fraction of its foragers this way, and the effect is almost never measurable in honey yield.
Queen mating is the one place where birds may matter. Virgin queens fly out on mating flights, and a bird taking a queen is a recognized cause of failed requeening, especially in small mating yards with many perches nearby. If you rear queens, place mating nucs away from dead snags and wires where flycatchers sit, and keep a record of failed matings so that you can see whether a location is a problem. See Mating Nucs: Types and Use for setup.
Do not alter your management over a few birds. Spend your effort on winter protection, where one bird can do real harm.
Placement and long-term strategies
Site matters. Hives near woodlots and old trees draw more woodpecker attention, since woodpeckers live there. Shelter from the wind can lessen the need for loud, bare walls. Consider painting or finishing boxes. See Painting and Preserving Bee Equipment for protective finishes that keep wood sound.
Keep the area free of dead wood that attracts woodpeckers. In regions where woodpecker damage is common, wrap hives routinely, as part of fall preparation. Check wraps through the winter, especially after storms.
Teach youth beekeepers that predation is a normal part of beekeeping, and that the response should be thoughtful and legal. Birds eating a few bees in summer is not a problem, whereas winter woodpecker damage deserves a quick, physical fix.
FAQ
Why do woodpeckers attack beehives in winter?
They hear the cluster buzzing, and insects are scarce in winter. They drill into the wall to reach the bees. Wraps and hardware cloth stop them.
Can I shoot or poison a woodpecker that is damaging my hive?
No. Woodpeckers are protected in many places, and harming them is illegal. Use physical barriers and contact your state wildlife agency for advice.
Do birds eating foragers hurt a colony?
Rarely. A strong colony can absorb occasional losses. Only act if the colony is small or birds are targeting the hive itself.