Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Equipment & Hive Types › Queen Excluders: Metal vs. Plastic

Equipment & Hive Types

Queen Excluders: Metal vs. Plastic

A queen excluder is a grid with openings large enough for workers but too small for the larger queen, used to keep her out of the honey supers so they contain honey rather than brood. Excluders come in several materials: wire, punched metal, wood-and-wire, and moulded plastic. Each has real strengths and weaknesses for bees and beekeepers. This article compares metal and plastic excluders on performance, durability, bee passage, cost and maintenance, and explains how to choose and use one. For the broader question of whether to use an excluder at all, see Queen Excluders: Pros, Cons, and Proper Use.

What the grid must do

An excluder must meet two conditions: the queen cannot pass, and workers pass easily. The key dimension is the slot width. Workers pass through slots of roughly 4.1 to 4.2 mm, while the queen's thorax is too wide. Drones are larger than workers and cannot pass either, so drones can become trapped above the excluder if they are in the supers. The quality of an excluder is how consistently it holds these dimensions.

Poor excluders have uneven slots, burrs, or warps. A queen may slip through a gap, or workers may be reluctant to cross, which slows honey storage. For how excluders fit in a hive, see Langstroth Hive: The Standard Explained and Adding Supers: Timing and Configuration.

Metal excluders

Metal excluders include welded wire grids and punched or slotted sheet metal, often framed in wood or metal.

Wire grid excluders (welded wire in a frame):

  • Pros: durable, rigid, excellent slot accuracy when well made, long lifespan, easy to scrape clean.
  • Cons: sharp edges can tear wings and damage bees, wire can bend if dropped, and cost can be high for good ones.

Punched sheet metal:

  • Pros: flat, smooth and uniform; bees pass easily if burrs are removed.
  • Cons: edges can be sharp, and metal can rust if the coating fails.

Many experienced keepers prefer metal because it keeps its shape, is consistent, and lasts decades. Bees often seem to pass wire grids more readily than plastic. However, weight and cost may matter for a large operation.

Plastic excluders

Plastic excluders are moulded sheets with slots, often framed or unframed.

Pros:

  • Inexpensive, lightweight and widely available.
  • Smooth edges that are gentler on bee wings.
  • Resistant to rust and corrosion.

Cons:

  • Can warp in heat, creating gaps that a queen can pass through.
  • Slots can be uneven in cheap products, or cause bees to hesitate.
  • Bees often glue them with propolis and wax, and scraping is more difficult.
  • Less durable and more likely to crack.

Plastic excluders are fine for hobbyists who inspect regularly and replace them when they warp. Check them against a straight edge each season.

Bee passage and honey production

There is a long-standing debate about whether excluders reduce honey yield, with some beekeepers calling them "honey excluders". Bees may be reluctant to cross, especially if the excluder is the only way up and there is no drawn comb above it. A well-made excluder with smooth slots is less of a barrier. Practical steps to reduce hesitation:

  • Place drawn comb or a few partially filled frames above the excluder to attract bees.
  • Add the excluder after supers are filling rather than at the start of a flow.
  • Keep the excluder clean of burr comb and propolis.
  • Ensure there is enough space and ventilation below.

Whether yield is affected varies with colony, flow and equipment, and published findings differ, so test on your own hives. Compare with a hive without an excluder if you can.

Which is better

There is no absolute answer. I would summarise:

FactorMetal (wire grid)Plastic
Slot accuracyExcellent when well madeVariable
DurabilityVery highModerate; can warp
Bee comfortEdges can be sharpSmooth
CostHigherLower
CleaningEasy to scrapeMore difficult
Heat resistanceExcellentCan warp

If you can afford it, a good metal excluder is a long-term investment. For beginners on a budget, a plastic excluder is acceptable, provided you check it. Wooden-framed wire excluders add a bee-space rim that prevents brace comb between boxes, which many keepers appreciate. Compare the equipment in Deep vs. Medium vs. Shallow Boxes when matching excluder size to your boxes.

Installing and maintaining an excluder

  1. Check fit. The excluder should match your box size, with a rim or bee space.
  2. Inspect slots. Hold it to the light, look for blocked slots, warping or burrs.
  3. Place it above the brood boxes and below the supers, after the queen is confirmed in the brood nest.
  4. Check for brood above the excluder at each inspection; if found, the queen may have passed or been trapped above.
  5. Clean it by scraping propolis and wax, ideally at harvest.
  6. Store flat in a dry place, and check for warping each year.

If your colony swarms with an excluder in place, the swarm may be blocked, so be aware of the risk and inspect for queen cells before the flow; see Reproductive Swarming: Triggers and Sequence.

Testing and sourcing a good excluder

Quality varies far more than price suggests, so test before you buy a quantity. Hold the grid up to a light and look along the slots for burrs, uneven gaps or bent wires, and lay it on a flat surface to check that it does not rock. A well-made unit feels rigid, and the edges of the slots are smooth to the touch. Buy from a supplier that states slot width, and be wary of unmarked imports with irregular spacing. If you run several hives, buy one extra and compare how bees behave on it against your standard type over a season.

Wood-bound wire excluders deserve a mention. The wood rim provides bee space and a sturdy frame, but it can warp or rot if left unpainted, so treat the outer edges. Frameless metal grids need a separate rim or spacer in some hives, or bees will fill the gap with comb. Whichever you choose, label the boxes and excluders in your apiary so they go back to the same hives, since colonies vary in how readily they pass a given grid.

Common mistakes

  • Putting an excluder on a colony with a queen above it.
  • Leaving drones trapped above the excluder, which can block the passage.
  • Using a warped plastic excluder that lets the queen through.
  • Placing excluders on a colony that has not drawn supers yet and expecting rapid storage.
  • Ignoring swarm cells while the excluder is on.
  • Forgetting to remove the excluder when overwintering; the cluster may be trapped below it, and the queen can become isolated from stores.

For breeders using excluders to separate queens and cells, see Queen Excluder Management for Breeders.

FAQ

Do queen excluders reduce honey production?

Some beekeepers report slower storage because bees hesitate to pass through, but results vary with the excluder, the flow and the colony, so test it on your own hives.

Are plastic excluders reliable?

They can be if they are well made and checked yearly, but heat can warp them and create gaps, so replace any that no longer lie flat.

Should I leave the excluder on in winter?

No, remove it before winter so the queen and cluster can move freely to reach stores.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →