Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Equipment & Hive Types › Deep vs. Medium vs. Shallow Boxes

Equipment & Hive Types

Deep vs. Medium vs. Shallow Boxes

Langstroth boxes come in three common heights, and the choice among them shapes your back, your budget, and the way you manage the colony. Deeps hold the most but weigh the most; mediums are a compromise; shallows are the easiest to lift and best for honey. This article explains the dimensions, compares weights and capacity, covers the pros and cons of an all-medium apiary versus a mixed system, and gives practical guidance on frame width and box count. The numbers are typical, since manufacturers vary slightly, so measure your own gear.

The three sizes and their typical dimensions

The usual box heights are about:

  • Deep: 9 5/8 inches
  • Medium (also called Illinois): 6 5/8 inches
  • Shallow: 5 3/8 inches (sometimes 5 11/16 inches in some regions)

All use the same length and width for a given frame count: a 10-frame box is about 19 7/8 inches long and 16 1/4 inches wide, and an 8-frame box is narrower. Frame heights match box heights, so a deep frame cannot fit in a medium box.

Because of this, boxes with different heights are interchangeable in the stack, but frames are not. That leads to the central question: do you want one frame size throughout, or different sizes for brood and honey?

Weight and capacity

Weights depend on honey and comb, but a few rules of thumb hold. A full 10-frame deep often weighs somewhere around 80 pounds. A full 10-frame medium usually weighs closer to 50 to 60 pounds, and a full shallow lighter still. An 8-frame box is roughly 20 percent lighter than a 10-frame box of the same height.

BoxTypical full weight (10-frame)Best use
DeepAround 80 lbBrood nest, winter stores
MediumRoughly 50-60 lbBrood or honey
ShallowLighter, about 40 lbHoney, comb honey

If you routinely lift boxes alone, these differences determine how long you can keep bees. Many beekeepers who started with deeps switch to mediums in their forties or fifties, and some never regret it.

The traditional mixed system

The classic approach is two deep brood boxes with shallow or medium honey supers. Advantages:

  • Deeps give the queen a large, continuous brood area, and the bees can store plenty of winter honey in them.
  • Most books and extension guides assume it.
  • Deeps are widely available.

Disadvantages:

  • Heavy boxes, especially in fall when they are packed with stores.
  • Two frame sizes in the apiary, so honey frames cannot be used for brood or vice versa.
  • Splitting and equalising are less flexible.

If you run a mixed system, label the boxes clearly, and keep a consistent order of boxes across hives so the structure is predictable. For a refresher on the hive structure, see Langstroth Hive: The Standard Explained.

The all-medium system

All-medium beekeeping uses medium boxes for both brood and honey. Advantages:

  • Every frame is interchangeable, which simplifies splits, swaps and equalising.
  • Boxes are lighter.
  • A single box type reduces spare equipment.
  • Easier for people with limited strength.

Disadvantages:

  • Brood nests are split across two or three boxes, which can make a cluster less comfortable in cold weather.
  • More frames to inspect and more boxes to lift to see the brood.
  • Fewer secondhand options in some regions, and some supplier offerings are limited.
  • Winter stores spread across more boxes means more attention to cluster position.

In most climates, a colony does fine in three mediums for brood or a combination of deep and medium. Colder regions often require more attention to stores. For winter practices see Preparing Your Hive for Winter: First-Year Edition.

Eight-frame vs ten-frame

Box width is a separate decision. Eight-frame boxes weigh less, fit smaller yards and are popular with keepers who want lighter equipment. Colonies in eight-frame boxes often fill them quickly, so they may need more supers and attention to swarm prevention. Ten-frame boxes provide more room and are the default in most catalogues.

Some beekeepers use eight-frame mediums for everything. It is a lightweight, flexible system, though fewer frames per box can mean more boxes in the stack. Keep an eye on the total height of the hive, which can become unstable in wind unless you strap or weigh it.

Frames and foundation by size

Frame size determines the foundation, extractor basket and uncapping equipment you need. Medium frames fit most standard extractors, and deep frames fit in many but not all; check the basket size before you buy. Shallow frames fit in almost every machine. If you plan to extract, see Extractor Types: Tangential vs. Radial. For frame construction choices, see Frame Types: Wood, Plastic, and Foundationless.

Brood chamber design

Bees do not care about box height; they care about continuous comb. A queen prefers to lay across adjacent frames, and a vertical break between boxes can limit her movement, especially in cooler weather. In deeps, a single seam separates two boxes, while in mediums the brood nest may cross more seams. Colonies manage this well in most climates, but you can help by keeping the brood boxes tightly stacked and by keeping the entrance and hive tight against drafts. Managing queen movement is discussed in Queen Excluders: Pros, Cons, and Proper Use, which also affects honey super placement.

Choosing a system

  1. If your back is your limit: all-medium, eight-frame.
  2. If you buy nucs and used equipment locally: match what is common in your area.
  3. If you want maximum brood room with minimal boxes: deeps for brood.
  4. If you plan to make comb honey: shallow supers.
  5. If you plan to expand: choose one system early and commit.

Whatever you choose, buy a single set at a time, test the fit, and stay consistent.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Mixing sizes without labels.
  • Choosing deeps for honey supers and then not being able to lift them.
  • Failing to check extractor compatibility.
  • Buying cheap boxes with poorly cut joints, which warp.
  • Assuming medium brood boxes make bees swarm less; swarming depends on management, not box height. See Reproductive Swarming: Triggers and Sequence.

Storage, stacking and the back

Box size changes how you work, not only what you buy. A tall stack of deeps puts the lowest box well below knee level once you have added supers, so every inspection involves heavy lifting at awkward angles. A few habits help whatever size you use:

  • Raise the hive on a stand so the bottom box is at a comfortable height; see Hive Stands: Why You Need One and How to Build It.
  • Use a lifting strap or a hive lifter for full boxes.
  • Take boxes apart in sections, removing frames from a heavy box before lifting it.
  • Keep a spare empty box beside the hive as a working platform for frames.
  • Store extra equipment in the size you use most, so every spare fits every hive.

Decide on a maximum weight you are willing to lift and let it guide the box choice. A beekeeper who can comfortably manage 50 pounds will have a longer, happier career with mediums than with deeps, and the bees will not know the difference.

FAQ

Can I use a deep frame in a medium box?

No, deep frames are taller and will not fit, and the opposite combination leaves large gaps that the bees fill with burr comb.

Are all-medium hives okay for winter?

Yes, colonies winter well in mediums in many climates, provided the cluster has stores adjacent to it and the hive is well ventilated and protected.

How heavy is a full honey super?

It varies with size and frame count, but a full 10-frame medium commonly weighs around 50 to 60 pounds, and a full deep is considerably heavier.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →