Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Hive Management by Season › Queen Excluders: Pros, Cons, and Proper Use

Hive Management by Season

Queen Excluders: Pros, Cons, and Proper Use

A queen excluder is a grid with openings large enough for workers but too small for the queen's thorax. Placed between the brood boxes and the honey supers, it confines egg laying to the lower boxes, so the honey above is free of brood. Few pieces of equipment divide beekeepers as sharply. Some call the excluder a vital tool, and others call it a "honey excluder." This article describes what excluders do, how they are made, the real advantages and disadvantages, and where they are used to best effect in an apiary.

How an excluder works

The queen has a larger thorax than a worker, which prevents her from passing through gaps of about 4.1-4.4 mm (roughly 0.163 inch). Workers pass freely, but drones are larger still and cannot pass. A drone that emerges above an excluder is therefore trapped, and a pile of dead drones in a super is a sign that brood was left above the barrier.

By restricting the queen to the brood boxes, you keep the supers free of brood. This makes extraction cleaner, because brood and larvae in honey comb produce dark, stained wax and can contaminate honey. The queen also tends to lay up the entire brood nest instead of walking upward into a honey super that is half empty. For fuller treatment of the biology of queen laying, see The Queen: Her Role, Lifespan, and Replacement.

Metal, plastic and wood-bound types

Excluders come as wire grids in wooden frames, slotted metal sheets, and moulded plastic. Wire excluders are durable and widely used. Slotted metal tends to offer cleaner edges that are less likely to snag bees' wings. Plastic is cheap but can warp and may have rough edges. A detailed comparison is in Queen Excluders: Metal vs. Plastic.

Bee space around the frame matters. A poorly fitted excluder can leave gaps where the queen can slip around or too much space where bees build burr comb. Make sure the excluder is flat, clean and well fitted. Wooden-bound excluders can be bulky and promote propolis build-up, whereas wire ones are lighter but may bend. Check every excluder for burrs and damage before the season.

The case for using one

The main advantage is brood-free honey. If you extract, brood in honey supers is a nuisance. It forces you to sort frames, leaves dark comb, and may make bees reluctant to give up supers at harvest. Excluders also help keep pollen-laden brood comb out of surplus frames, and they simplify honey and comb-honey production, as covered in Managing for Comb Honey Production.

They also make management easier in some circumstances. A colony with an excluder under supers lets you take supers without worrying about finding the queen. They can be used in more advanced manipulations, including queen-rearing and two-queen systems; see Double-Queen Systems: Advanced Management and Queen Excluder Management for Breeders. For beekeepers with many colonies, the excluder gives predictable results with little inspection.

The case against

The most common complaint is that excluders reduce honey production by discouraging bees from moving up. Many beekeepers have seen bees hesitate to cross the barrier, store nectar in the brood nest instead, and become honey-bound. Whether this effect is large depends on the colony, the flow and the type of excluder, and different research and field experience point both ways, so treat claims on either side with caution.

Excluders also trap drones, can crowd the colony and may increase swarming if bees feel congested. Bees can build burr comb on the excluder, making supers hard to lift off. Cleaning excluders is a chore. Beekeepers who run without excluders accept some brood in supers and manage it by using smaller supers or by moving brood frames down.

When to use an excluder

Use an excluder if you produce extracted or comb honey and want clean frames, if you have a short flow and need predictable boxes, or if you wish to pull supers without searching for the queen. Avoid using one in a colony that has just been hived or in an overcrowded brood nest where the queen needs room.

A good compromise is to use the excluder only when it helps: put it on when the supers are being filled and bees are accustomed to going up, and remove it at the end of the flow. If you need to reduce swarming, make sure that the colony has ample brood room first, and keep the brood nest open. See Swarm Season: Prevention and Management and Adding Supers: Timing and Configuration for how excluders fit into swarm control.

Installing and managing excluders

  1. Inspect the brood boxes and confirm that the queen is below the excluder; if she is above, move her down.
  2. Place the excluder over the top brood box, with the wide bars perpendicular to the frames if it has a rim.
  3. Add the super and check that bees are moving up within a few days.
  4. If bees are slow, put a frame of honey or a partly drawn frame in the lower super to lure them.
  5. Check weekly for burr comb, drone corpses and brood below.
  6. Remove the excluder promptly at the end of the flow to avoid trapping the queen in a super during harvest.

Mark your hive tools and boxes so that the queen is never accidentally placed above an excluder.

Alternatives to excluders

Beekeepers who dislike excluders use other approaches. One is to run supers without them and accept occasional brood, extracting carefully, or leaving brood frames until the brood emerges. Another is to use shallow supers that the queen is less inclined to enter. A third is to rely on honey bound brood nests, where the queen stays low because the upper box contains honey.

Some beekeepers use queen traps to confine the queen temporarily, for example when removing brood for varroa control; see Queen Trapping: Breaking the Brood Cycle. Others use a split-board or top-entrance technique to manage swarms. Whichever you choose, understand the trade-offs. An excluder is a tool, not a rule.

Reading the signs after the excluder goes on

Within a week of fitting an excluder, look for evidence of how the colony is responding. Healthy signs are bees moving freely through the grid, nectar being stored in the super, and a brood nest that is still being laid up evenly. Warning signs are a super with no activity while the brood boxes are packed with nectar, bearding that was not there before, and queen cups appearing along the bottom bars of the frames.

If you see the warning signs, do not simply wait. Move a frame of capped honey or a partly drawn frame into the super, shift a couple of frames of emerging brood upstairs above the grid, or take the excluder off for a few days. Experienced beekeepers treat the excluder as something to be tuned to each colony, not installed once and forgotten. A strong colony in a heavy flow usually adapts within days, whereas a smaller colony in a light flow may never take to it.

FAQ

Do queen excluders reduce honey production?

They can in some colonies, if bees are reluctant to cross the barrier. Evidence is mixed, and many beekeepers use them successfully with careful management.

Can drones get through an excluder?

No. Drones are larger than workers and larger than the queen's thorax, so they are blocked, and any drones emerging above the excluder are trapped.

When should I remove the excluder?

Take it off at the end of the flow, usually when you pull supers, so that the queen is not trapped and the colony has room in the fall.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →