Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Queens & Breeding › Queen Excluder Management for Breeders

Queens & Breeding

Queen Excluder Management for Breeders

For a honey producer a queen excluder is a way to keep brood out of supers. For a queen breeder it is a precision tool: it confines a breeder queen to a single comb, separates cell-building colonies from laying queens, keeps virgins from leaving and lets you control the age of larvae you graft. Used well it makes queen rearing predictable; used badly it traps drones, starves bees or lets queens meet and fight. This article covers the breeder's uses of excluders, how to choose and fit them, how to avoid the common failures, and when to leave them off. For the general honey-production uses, see Queen Excluders: Pros, Cons, and Proper Use.

Why breeders use excluders differently

A breeder cares about where eggs are laid and on what day. An excluder gives you that information. If a queen is confined to one box or one comb for a measured number of days, every egg is a known age, which makes it possible to graft larvae of exactly the right age. The same device keeps a breeder queen out of a cell-builder unit, keeps queens out of honey, and allows several colonies to share one set of workers without sharing brood.

An excluder also changes the colony's behavior. Workers must squeeze through the slots, which reduces traffic slightly and can slow nectar movement. Breeders accept this because their goal is control, not maximum honey from every box.

Choosing the right excluder

Excluders are made of welded wire, slotted plastic or slotted metal; see Queen Excluders: Metal vs. Plastic. For breeding work:

  • Wire excluders with smooth, uniform gaps pass workers more easily and have little burr. Look for gaps that exclude queens and drones but allow workers freely.
  • Plastic excluders are lighter and cheaper but can warp and have sharp edges that injure bees. Check that slots are clean and consistent.
  • Wooden-framed excluders prevent burr comb on the edges and add bee space where needed.

Test an excluder before trusting it. A worn or damaged excluder with one wide slot lets a small queen through, which can ruin a trial. Hold it to the light, inspect each slot, and discard warped ones. Keep a dedicated set of excluders for breeder colonies so they are not mixed with equipment from colonies of unknown health.

Confining a breeder queen

The classic use is a one-comb or one-box cage so the queen lays in a chosen comb.

  1. Place the breeder queen in a queen-right colony with an empty, drawn comb in a box separated by an excluder, or place the comb in a small excluder cage fitted to the frame.
  2. Leave her on the comb for a set number of days, commonly about a day or two, so eggs are laid on a known schedule.
  3. Remove the comb and mark it with date and queen number.
  4. Return the comb to a nurse-rich colony and count three days before grafting from that comb, when larvae are of suitable age.
  5. Release the queen and let her resume normal laying.

Confining a queen for too long stresses her and reduces laying; keep the periods short and watch her condition. Many breeders prefer a comb-sized cage with a screened side, which allows attendants to feed her. See Queen Rearing Equipment: Grafting Tools and Cells for common designs and Grafting: The Doolittle Method for what happens next.

Using excluders with cell builders

A cell-building colony that is queenright but separated from the queen by an excluder can hold a large population of nurse bees that raise cells well. In this arrangement the queen stays below the excluder, the cells go above in a box with open brood and food, and nurse bees from below move up through the slots. Because nurses do the work, the system needs a strong population and plenty of young brood; see Queen Cell Builders and Starter/Finisher Colonies.

Check the following in the weeks of use:

  • The queen is below the excluder every time you inspect; a queen above it will destroy cells.
  • No emergency cells have formed in the lower box.
  • Feed is sufficient, either honey or syrup and pollen; see Feeding Bees: 4-H Project Responsibilities.
  • The excluder is clean of propolis blocks that restrict worker movement.

Mating yards, virgins and drones

Excluders also help with drone management. Drone-excluding entrance guards keep drones in or out of selected colonies, which lets breeders control which colonies supply mature drones near mating nucs. Queen excluders over mating nuc entrances can stop virgins from leaving until you want them to fly, but most experienced breeders prefer to rely on natural orientation and a small entrance reducer, because blocking virgins can trap workers and drones and cause overheating.

Drone traps and excluder entrances must be monitored daily in warm weather. Trapped drones die quickly in sun and heat, and a blocked entrance of a strong colony is dangerous for the colony. See Drone Flooding: Saturation Technique for placing selected drone sources.

Excluders and swarm control

In a breeding apiary you do not want unplanned swarms, since a swarm can carry away a valuable queen or leave your yard with unselected drones. An excluder can be used as part of swarm control by separating the queen and brood from the supers and cells; see Reproductive Swarming: Triggers and Sequence for the biology. Excluders do not stop swarming by themselves; they only confine the queen. A crowded colony may still raise cells and prepare to swarm, so combine excluder use with space management and regular inspection.

Common problems and fixes

ProblemLikely causeFix
Queen found above excluderGap, damaged slot or broken sealReplace the excluder, check the box edges
Bees reluctant to passToo little room, propolis, plastic slot too narrowClean slots, add space, allow bees to adapt
Drones trappedDrone passage blockedRemove or add drone escape
Burr comb on excluderToo much space above or belowReduce bee space, clean regularly
Queen killed after excluder failsGap lets queens meetCheck before each use

Check the excluder each time you open the colony. A few seconds of examination can prevent a lost queen.

When not to use an excluder

Skip excluders when:

  • A queen is weak or newly introduced and needs the whole nest to build up.
  • The colony is small and every bee is needed in the brood nest.
  • A colony is about to be moved to a strong flow with little room.
  • You can accomplish the same goal with a simple box separation or a screened divider.

Breeders sometimes overuse equipment. If a simpler method works, use it. A good record of what you did and what happened helps you decide which tools are worth the effort; see Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs.

FAQ

Can a queen pass through a queen excluder?

A properly sized, undamaged excluder blocks her, but warped or worn ones sometimes fail, and a small virgin or a thin young queen can pass a marginal slot. Inspect the excluder and test it before relying on it.

How long can I confine a breeder queen to a comb?

Short periods, usually a day or two, are enough to get eggs of known age. Longer confinement stresses her, so watch her condition and release her promptly.

Do excluders reduce honey yield?

In honey production they can slow worker movement slightly, though results vary. In breeding they are used for control, and a small effect on honey is usually acceptable.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →