Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Pests, Diseases & Health › Necropsy: What to Look for in a Dead Colony

Pests, Diseases & Health

Necropsy: What to Look for in a Dead Colony

When a colony dies, the hive becomes a record of what happened, if you know how to read it. A careful dead-out examination, called a necropsy, can tell you whether the colony starved, froze, was overwhelmed by Varroa, lost its queen, or died of disease. It can also tell you whether the equipment is safe to reuse. Many beekeepers simply clean out a dead hive and move on, learning nothing and risking repeating the same loss. This article provides a systematic method: what to look at, in what order, what each finding suggests, and when to send samples to a laboratory.

Before you open the box

Plan the examination. Choose a time when it is safe to open the hive and when robbing is not a risk, usually in a cool period or at a time when bees are not flying. If the dead-out is in winter and other colonies are alive, work quickly and close the entrance of the dead hive to prevent robbing.

Wear protective gear, in case some bees are still alive. Take a camera, notebook, hive tool, clean containers or bags for samples, a marker, and gloves. If disease is a possibility, use disposable gloves and change them between frames or colonies as needed.

Before opening, observe the outside. Look at the entrance for dead bees, droppings, mouse damage, and evidence of robbing or ants. Note the position of the hive, how much snow or water is around, and whether the entrance is blocked. Record the date, the apiary, the hive number, and the history, including the last inspection, mite counts, and treatments.

Reading the bottom board and entrance

Start at the bottom. The pile of dead bees on the bottom board is informative.

Scrape debris into a container and look at it. Mites can sometimes be found among dead bees. Pests that are present are usually secondary, and not the cause.

Look at the dead bees. Bees with heads in cells and tails sticking out suggest starvation. Look at the position of the cluster, which should be relative to the stores.

Starvation, cold and queen failure

Different causes have different signs.

FindingLikely cause
Bees head-first in empty cells, no honey nearbyStarvation
Cluster dead with honey a few frames awayIsolation starvation in cold, cluster could not move
Small cluster, no brood, queen dead or missingQueen failure or queenlessness
Plenty of stores, dead cluster, wet interiorMoisture and cold stress
Dry, scattered dead bees, little clusterAbsconding or very late loss

Starvation is common in winter and early spring, particularly when brood rearing resumes and stores run out. Look closely at honey location. A cluster can starve with honey on the edge of the box, if cold prevents movement. Compare with Winter Cluster Dynamics: Heat Generation and Survival to understand cluster movement.

Check for the queen among the dead bees. If you find her, note whether she looks normal. A failing queen, with a drone-laying pattern in the remaining comb, suggests that the colony went queenless; see Queenlessness: Signs and Timing.

Signs of Varroa and virus collapse

Varroa collapse is the most common cause of fall and winter loss. The classic picture is a colony that looked strong in late summer, shrank rapidly in autumn, and had few bees in winter, often with plenty of honey. Look for:

  • Deformed wings on dead bees.
  • Brown mite droppings, white-ish crusts on the upper walls of cells.
  • Spotty or abnormal brood, if any remains.
  • Mites on bees, if you check by alcohol wash. See Varroa Monitoring: Alcohol Wash vs. Sugar Roll.
  • Evidence that the colony was robbed late in the season, which may bring mites into neighboring colonies.

These findings point to Varroa and deformed wing virus. See Deformed Wing Virus (DWV): The Varroa Connection and Varroa Destructor: The Beekeeper's Primary Enemy. If you did not monitor mites last fall, you may be unable to prove it, but the pattern is highly suggestive. Use the results to adjust your mite program in the future. See Integrated Pest Management for Varroa.

Brood disease and other pathogens

If brood remains, examine it closely. Look at cappings. Sunken, dark, perforated cappings, and ropy, brown larval remains, suggest American foulbrood. Contorted, twisted larvae that are yellowish or brown and have a sour smell suggest European foulbrood. Hard, white or gray mummies suggest chalkbrood. See American Foulbrood (AFB): Identification and Response, European Foulbrood (EFB): Stress-Related Disease and Chalkbrood: Fungal Infection Management.

Never test for AFB by sniffing deeply or tasting. Use a clean stick for the rope test and wear gloves. If you suspect AFB, stop. Close the hive tightly, do not move frames, and contact your state apiarist. The disease is regulated in many places, and equipment from AFB colonies must be handled according to regulations. See Foulbrood Spore Detection: Testing Options and AFB Eradication: Burning and Irradiation.

For adult diseases, such as Nosema, look for brown streaking on the combs and walls from dysentery, though this is also seen in cold or long confinement. Spore counts require a laboratory or microscope. See Nosema Diagnosis and Treatment.

Checking for pesticides and other causes

Sudden loss of many foragers with a normal brood nest may indicate pesticide exposure. If you suspect it, collect samples of dead bees quickly and contact authorities. See Pesticide Exposure: Recognizing and Responding.

Other causes include predators, such as bears and skunks; see Bears: Fencing and Deterrence and Skunks and Raccoons: Nocturnal Predators. Look for physical damage, tracks and tipped boxes. Check for flooding, wind damage, or an overheated hive.

Also consider management factors: Was the colony small going into winter? Was it queenright? Were there enough stores? Was the colony recently moved or divided? Did it have adequate ventilation? Combine your physical findings with your records to build a likely story.

Sampling, cleanup and records

If the cause is uncertain, collect samples.

  1. Collect about a hundred dead bees from the hive and bottom board, and freeze them.
  2. Collect a comb sample with brood, if present, cut into a clean container or wrapped in paper, not plastic, as the lab recommends.
  3. Photograph everything before cleaning.
  4. Contact your state apiarist, extension office, or a university laboratory for submission instructions. The state-by-state directory can help.

After the examination, close the hive and decide what to do with the equipment. If disease is suspected, do not reuse comb. Quarantine and follow inspector instructions. If the cause was starvation or cold, comb can usually be reused after checking for moth and mouse damage. Clean boxes with scraping and, if needed, scorching; see Apiary Hygiene: Equipment Cleaning and Disinfection. Store comb safely; see Wax Moth Control in Storage.

Write down your conclusions in a loss log. Over time, patterns appear. Record what you plan to change, such as improved mite control or more winter feed. See Emergency Colony Loss Response for steps in a larger loss. Youth beekeepers should perform necropsies with an adult, especially when disease is a possibility.

FAQ

When is the best time to do a necropsy?

As soon as you find the dead-out, in a cool period when robbing is unlikely. Close the entrance of the dead hive first, and photograph everything before cleaning.

Can I reuse comb from a dead colony?

If the cause was starvation or cold, usually yes after checking for moths, mice and mold. If disease is suspected, do not reuse it, and contact your state apiarist.

How do I tell Varroa collapse from starvation?

Starvation shows bees head-first in empty cells with no stores nearby. Varroa collapse leaves few bees and often plenty of honey, with deformed wings and mite signs.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →