Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Pests, Diseases & Health › Neonicotinoids and Bees: The Research

Pests, Diseases & Health

Neonicotinoids and Bees: The Research

Neonicotinoids are among the most studied and most debated insecticides in the history of bee science. Introduced in the 1990s, they became popular because they are effective against sucking and chewing pests at low doses and can be applied to seeds or soil, where plants take them up and carry them throughout their tissues, including pollen and nectar. Concern grew when beekeepers and scientists asked whether this systemic exposure harms bees. This article summarizes what the research shows, where the evidence is strong, where it is mixed, and how beekeepers should think about it.

What neonicotinoids are

Neonicotinoids are a class of insecticides that act on the nervous system of insects by binding to nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, causing overstimulation, paralysis and death. They are related in mode of action to nicotine. Common active ingredients include imidacloprid, clothianidin, thiamethoxam, acetamiprid and dinotefuran, though regulatory status differs between regions.

They are used in several ways: as seed treatments on crops such as corn, soybeans and canola; as soil drenches and injections for ornamental trees and shrubs; as foliar sprays; and in garden and lawn products. Because they are water-soluble and systemic, they can move into plant tissues and appear in pollen and nectar, depending on the application method, plant, and timing.

Seed treatment dust is another route. During planting, abraded dust can drift from planting equipment onto nearby flowers and bee colonies, causing acute exposure. Equipment changes and practices have addressed some of this problem. See Pesticide Exposure: Recognizing and Responding for exposure basics.

Lethal and sublethal effects

Neonicotinoids are highly toxic to bees at high doses, and they can cause acute kills when bees are directly sprayed or exposed to dust. At the doses typically found in nectar and pollen from treated crops, effects are usually sublethal, which means that bees do not die immediately.

Laboratory and field studies have examined sublethal effects, including impaired learning and memory, reduced foraging efficiency, impaired navigation, disrupted brood development, altered immune function, and reduced queen performance. Results vary by study, bee species, dose, and conditions. Some studies suggest a negative effect on honey bees at realistic doses, while others find small or no effects on colony health, in part because honey bee colonies can buffer individual bee losses.

The most consistent findings of harm come from studies of bumble bees and solitary bees, which have smaller colonies and less buffering capacity. See Neonicotinoids and Wild Bees and Pesticide Impacts on Native Bees.

What field studies found

Large field-scale studies have attempted to measure real-world effects. Some have found negative effects on colony growth, overwintering success or reproduction in wild bees exposed to treated crops. Others have found minimal effects on honey bee colony survival and honey production. The picture depends on crop, region, exposure level, and measurement approach.

Reasons for conflicting results include differences in study design, difficulty controlling exposure in open landscapes, and the fact that bees encounter many stressors at once. Combined effects with other pesticides, pathogens and poor nutrition are likely. Honey bee colonies are managed and fed, which may mask effects, whereas wild bees rely on natural resources.

Regulators have reviewed the evidence and, in some regions, decided to restrict uses. See Neonicotinoid Regulation: State and Federal for how rules differ. Because regulations change, verify current status with the agency in your region.

Honey bees versus wild bees

There is an important difference in risk between managed honey bees and wild bees.

FactorHoney beesWild bees
Colony sizeThousands of workersFew individuals, or solitary
RedundancyHigh, losses can be bufferedLow, loss of one female matters
ManagementFed, treated, movedNone
ExposureLarge foraging range, variedOften local to treated plants
Evidence of harmMixedMore consistent

This is why many conservation-focused scientists emphasize wild bees in the neonicotinoid debate, while beekeepers focus on colony-level effects. Both perspectives matter. Garden and landscape uses may be important for native bees even when crop uses seem to have little effect on hives.

Reading the research critically

When you see a headline about neonicotinoids, ask a few questions.

  1. What species was studied? Honey bee, bumble bee, or solitary bee results are not interchangeable.
  2. What dose and exposure route? Lab dosing may be higher or lower than field exposure.
  3. Lab or field? Field studies are more realistic but harder to control.
  4. What outcome? Individual bee behavior is different from colony survival.
  5. Who funded and who reviewed the study? Look for peer-reviewed work and replication.

Avoid both extremes. Claims that neonicotinoids are the single cause of bee declines are not supported by the evidence, since Varroa, viruses, nutrition and weather play major roles. Claims that they are harmless are also not supported, particularly for wild bees. See Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD): Still Relevant? for a related discussion.

What beekeepers can do

Practical steps for beekeepers include:

  • Learn what is applied near your yards. Ask neighboring farmers about seed treatments and spray programs.
  • Avoid planting or buying treated plants for your garden. Ask nurseries whether ornamental plants have been treated with systemic insecticides.
  • Provide clean water and diverse forage so that bees do not rely on a single treated crop. See Planting a Bee Garden: Forage for All Seasons.
  • Document unusual losses and report suspected kills; see Pesticide Exposure: Recognizing and Responding.
  • Follow the label for any pesticide you use, and never apply insecticides to flowering plants.
  • Stay informed about regulations and research.

If you teach youth, help them understand that science is a process, and that conflicting results are part of the work. Encourage them to read summaries from reliable organizations such as the Bee Informed Partnership and the Honey Bee Health Coalition.

Regulation and verification

Regulation of neonicotinoids varies widely. Some regions have restricted outdoor use of certain active ingredients, while others allow them with label requirements. Rules also differ between agricultural, ornamental and consumer products. In the United States, the Environmental Protection Agency registers pesticides, and states may add their own restrictions. Verify current rules with your state department of agriculture and the relevant agency, since regulations and label requirements change.

Because labels are the law, read them. Many labels now include pollinator protection statements, restrictions on application during bloom, and warnings about drift. If you see an application that appears to violate a label, contact your state agency.

For related equipment and site decisions, see Siting Your Apiary: Sun, Wind, Water, and Neighbors. Remember that no single measure protects your bees. Healthy colonies with low Varroa loads and good nutrition are more resilient to pesticide stress.

FAQ

Are neonicotinoids the main cause of honey bee losses?

No single cause explains losses. Varroa and the viruses it spreads are generally considered the leading factor, with nutrition, weather and pesticides also contributing.

Why are wild bees considered more at risk than honey bees?

Wild bees have smaller colonies or are solitary, so they have less buffering against losses, and many rely entirely on local forage that may be treated.

How can I avoid neonicotinoids in my garden?

Ask nurseries whether plants were treated with systemic insecticides, choose untreated plants or seeds, and avoid applying insecticides to flowering plants. Always follow product labels.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →