Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Pests, Diseases & Health › European Foulbrood (EFB): Stress-Related Disease

Pests, Diseases & Health

European Foulbrood (EFB): Stress-Related Disease

European foulbrood, or EFB, is a bacterial disease of honey bee larvae caused mainly by Melissococcus plutonius. Unlike American foulbrood, it usually kills larvae before they are capped and does not form durable spores, and it often appears when colonies are stressed, especially during spring buildup or periods of poor forage. It can look alarming but is generally less persistent than AFB. Still, it can weaken colonies and it can be confused with AFB, so confirmation matters. This article explains how to recognize EFB, why it is called stress-related, how it differs from other brood diseases, and how to manage it.

What EFB Is

Melissococcus plutonius is a bacterium that infects young larvae through contaminated food. It multiplies in the larval midgut, competing with the larva for food. Infected larvae often die from starvation before they are capped, typically at around four to five days old. Secondary bacteria may then invade and cause odors and discoloration.

The disease is considered stress-related because colonies with a good supply of nurse bees and food often clear it on their own. When nurse bees are scarce, such as during rapid buildup, after swarming, or in cold snaps, larvae may be underfed, and infection takes hold. Poor nutrition, chilling, and other stresses increase risk.

Some strains of the bacterium are more virulent than others, and in some regions EFB has become a more serious problem. Check current local guidance. In many jurisdictions it is a reportable disease, so ask your state apiarist or inspector.

Signs of EFB

Look at open larvae and young brood first. Signs include:

  • Twisted larvae. Larvae lie in unnatural positions in their cells, often twisted around the cell wall or curled upward, rather than lying in the normal coiled "C" shape
  • Discoloration. Larvae turn yellowish, then brown, with the trachea visible as a whitish line
  • Melted or deflated appearance. Larvae look collapsed and watery
  • Spotty brood pattern. Mixed ages with gaps, because dead larvae are removed
  • Sour smell. Often compared to sour or fermenting odors, in contrast to the glue-like smell of AFB
  • Dead larvae not ropey. They may be stringy in some cases, but not as consistently as AFB

Compare your frame with a healthy brood pattern; see Recognizing a Healthy Brood Pattern. Healthy larvae are plump, pearly white and curled in the bottom of the cell. See Brood Development Stages by Day for the normal timeline.

EFB or AFB?

Because the two diseases can look similar, confusion is common, and misdiagnosis is risky. AFB is far more serious. If you cannot tell the difference, treat the situation as possible AFB until tested.

FeatureEFBAFB
Stage killedMostly uncapped larvaeMostly capped larvae and pupae
Larval positionTwisted, meltedSunken, brown, flat
SmellSourFoul, glue-like
RopinessUsually absent or weakPositive, ropy
ScalesRubbery, easily removedHard, adhering to cell wall
SporesNot durableExtremely durable

See American Foulbrood (AFB): Identification and Response for AFB identification. Lateral flow test kits exist for both diseases, but results should be confirmed through a lab. Your state apiary program can test samples, often at no cost. Do not rely on your eyes alone.

Other conditions can mimic EFB, including Sacbrood Virus: Identification and Impact, chilled brood and starvation. Confirm before acting.

Why Stress Matters

EFB tends to appear when the ratio of nurse bees to larvae is out of balance. Situations that raise risk include:

  1. Rapid spring buildup, with brood expanding faster than the nurse population
  2. Cold snaps that cause the cluster to contract, leaving brood chilled and unfed
  3. Dearth periods, when nectar and pollen are scarce
  4. Colony splits, swarms and shaken-swarm management that reduce nurse bees
  5. Pollination stress and transport
  6. High varroa or virus loads
  7. Poor-quality or limited pollen
  8. Pesticide exposure

Because of this, much of EFB management is about reducing stress and supporting the colony. Where possible, avoid actions that pull nurse bees away from brood during stressful periods. See Spring Feeding: Syrup Ratios and Methods and Pollen Patties and Substitutes for support.

Managing an EFB Colony

Management depends on severity and local rules. Mild cases often clear when conditions improve. Typical non-chemical steps:

Inspect again after a couple of weeks to see if brood is improving. Keep records; see Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs.

Antibiotics can suppress EFB, and in some jurisdictions they are allowed with veterinary oversight. In the United States, antibiotic use in bees requires a veterinarian's involvement and compliance with the label. I will not provide doses or mixing procedures. Never use antibiotics without a prescription or veterinary feed directive where required, and never as a routine preventive measure.

Antibiotics do not address the underlying stress, can leave residues in honey, and promote resistance. Many experts recommend trying management changes first, especially in mild cases, and using drugs only when needed and under supervision.

Because regulations differ, check with your state apiarist, USDA APHIS and the state-by-state directory. If EFB is reportable in your area, notify the agency. They can confirm the diagnosis and advise on handling equipment.

Preventing Spread and Recurrence

EFB bacteria do not form long-lived spores, but they can persist in comb and hive materials for some time, and they spread through robbing, drifting and shared equipment. To limit spread:

Recurrence may suggest underlying problems such as poor nutrition, forage gaps or high mite levels. Look at the whole management system, not just the disease.

Common Mistakes

  • Assuming sour smell means EFB without testing
  • Confusing EFB with AFB or sacbrood
  • Using antibiotics routinely
  • Combining sick and healthy colonies
  • Ignoring nutrition and forage
  • Leaving stressed colonies in poor locations
  • Taking too many nurse bees for splits
  • Not controlling mites
  • Failing to inspect again after improvement
  • Not telling the inspector when required

FAQ

Is EFB as serious as AFB?

Usually not, because it does not form durable spores and often clears when stress eases, but it can weaken colonies and must be distinguished from AFB by testing.

Why does EFB appear in spring?

Rapid buildup and cold snaps can leave too few nurse bees for the larvae, so underfed larvae become susceptible to the bacterium.

Can I use antibiotics for EFB?

In the United States antibiotic use in bees requires a veterinarian and label compliance, and management changes such as nutrition, requeening and mite control should come first.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →