Bees sometimes need help with food: new colonies drawing comb, colonies heading into winter light, starved nucs in a dearth, or queens that need syrup in mating nucs. The equipment you use to deliver that food matters as much as the recipe. The main types are the Boardman entrance feeder, the top feeder, the frame feeder, the pail or bucket feeder, and plastic bags. This article compares them, covers capacity, drowning, robbing and cleaning issues, and offers a way to choose. I have built and tested most of these designs, and each has strengths and annoying habits.
Why feeders matter
A feeder determines how safely and efficiently syrup reaches your bees. A good feeder:
- Holds enough syrup for several days.
- Lets bees reach the food without drowning.
- Does not invite robbing or leak.
- Is easy to fill and clean.
- Fits your hive and your climate.
A poor feeder can drown bees, chill the cluster, attract wasps and ants, or sit empty because bees cannot reach it in cold weather. Before you buy, think about when you will feed. Spring feeding, fall feeding and emergency feeding have different needs; see Spring Feeding: Syrup Ratios and Methods, Fall Feeding: 2:1 Syrup and Fondant and Emergency Winter Feeding: Candy Boards and Mountain Camp.
Boardman entrance feeders
The Boardman is a jar that sits upside-down in a block at the hive entrance. Bees take syrup from a small tray inside the entrance block.
Pros:
- Cheap and easy to fill.
- Lets you see the level without opening the hive.
- Useful for small colonies and nucs.
Cons:
- Small capacity, usually a quart.
- Encourages robbing, since the syrup is at the entrance.
- Bees must leave the cluster in cool weather to reach it.
- Can leak and soak the entrance.
I rarely recommend them except for small colonies in mild weather. For robbing risks, see Robbing Behavior: Prevention and Response. A full comparison is in Entrance Feeders vs. In-Hive Feeders.
Top feeders
A top feeder sits on top of the hive body, below the inner cover or a rim. Bees climb in through a slot and take syrup from a reservoir. Designs include the Miller (a shallow pan with a central access) and the Pierce-style or inner-cover feeders.
Pros:
- Large capacity, often one to two gallons.
- Bees feed inside the hive, away from robbers.
- You can refill with minimal disturbance.
Cons:
- Bees can drown if flotation is poor; use floats or screens.
- Syrup can ferment or mould if left too long.
- Heavier and bulkier to handle.
- You need an extra box to cover the feeder.
Top feeders are the workhorse for spring and fall feeding in most climates.
Frame feeders
A frame feeder is a plastic container the size of a frame that hangs in the hive in place of one or two frames. Bees reach the syrup through a ladder or a central slot.
Pros:
- Keeps syrup inside the cluster area, where bees are warm.
- Works well in cool weather.
- Does not require extra boxes.
Cons:
- Smaller capacity than a top feeder.
- Bees can drown without proper floats.
- You must open the hive to refill.
- Takes frame space.
In nucs and small hives, a frame feeder placed next to the cluster is very effective.
Pail and bucket feeders
A bucket feeder is a pail with tiny holes in the lid, inverted over a hole in the inner cover, with an empty box around it. It is excellent for large volumes of syrup with minimal disturbance. See Bucket Feeders and Pail Feeders.
Baggie feeders
A zip-top bag filled with syrup is laid on top of frames and slit with a clean blade. It is cheap and requires no special equipment, but it needs an empty box to cover it, it can leak, and the bag is disposable. Use heavy-duty bags and pierce them only on the top. For a nuc or a small colony, it is surprisingly good.
Choosing the right feeder
| Situation | Suggested feeder |
|---|---|
| New package or nuc in spring | Frame feeder or top feeder |
| Large colonies building comb | Top feeder or pail |
| Fall feeding for winter stores | Top feeder or pail; large volume, quickly |
| Mating nucs | Small frame or entrance feeders |
| Emergency winter feeding | Fondant, candy board, or dry sugar on top; see Fondant and Candy Boards |
| Mild climate with few robbers | Entrance feeder is acceptable |
Match the feeder to the weather and to colony size. In cool weather, bees often will not break cluster to reach a feeder, so use an in-hive design directly above or beside the cluster.
Preventing drowning, robbing and mould
- Floats and ladders: include a raft of wood, mesh or plastic so bees can stand safely.
- Feed in the evening: it reduces robbing and bee flight.
- Do not spill: syrup on the ground draws wasps and robbers; fix leaks.
- Reduce entrances: during a dearth, reduce entrances and consider a screen; see Robbing Screens: Installation and Use.
- Change syrup: do not leave syrup sitting for weeks. Replace if it ferments or moulds.
- Clean feeders: wash with hot water and let them dry between uses.
Feeding responsibly
Feeding should solve a problem, not become a habit. Do not feed syrup when supers are on, because it can end up in your honey. Use plain white sugar, not brown sugar, honey of unknown origin or other sweeteners. Follow current guidance from your extension office on ratios and timing. Colonies that need constant feeding often have bigger problems, such as queenlessness or mite damage, that feeding will not cure. For broader context see Feeding Bees: 4-H Project Responsibilities and Summer Feeding: When Nectar Stops.
Sizing, syrup and timing basics
Match the amount you offer to the colony. A nucleus colony may take only a pint or two at a time, and a full-sized colony in fall can take a gallon or more in a few days. Over-feeding a small colony fills the brood nest with syrup, which squeezes out the queen and can trigger swarm preparations, so give what the bees can take in a few days and refill as needed. A rough guide is to feed in small, regular amounts in spring and larger amounts in fall, while the weather is still warm enough for bees to process and cap it.
Always check the local advice from your extension office, since ratios and timing vary by region. Keep a log of dates, volumes and weather so you can see what your bees actually take. If you find a feeder untouched for several days, find out why before refilling it. The cause may be a cold snap, a strong natural flow, or a queenless colony that has stopped building, and sometimes the feeder simply is not reachable from the cluster.
FAQ
Which feeder is best for a beginner?
A top feeder or a frame feeder is usually the easiest, because the bees feed inside the hive and you can fill them without attracting robbers.
Do bees drown in feeders?
They can if there is no way to climb out, so choose a feeder with floats, ladders or screens, and check it regularly.
Can I leave a feeder in the hive all year?
Generally no; remove feeders when you do not need them, especially when supers are on or in winter, and clean them before storing.