Pollen is the bees' protein, fat, vitamin and mineral source, and brood rearing depends on it. When natural pollen is scarce, in late winter, early spring, or during a summer dearth, beekeepers sometimes feed pollen patties or substitutes. Used well, they can support colony build-up. Used poorly, they can attract pests, waste money, and substitute for management that should have addressed the real problem. This article explains what pollen supplements are, how they differ, how to feed them, when they help, and when to skip them. I have tested patties and dry mixes in different seasons, and the results depend heavily on local conditions.
Pollen versus substitute
Pollen supplements fall into three groups:
- Pollen patties contain real pollen, often trapped pollen, mixed with sugar and sometimes substitute ingredients.
- Pollen substitutes contain no pollen, using ingredients such as soy flour, brewer's yeast, casein or other proteins and vitamins.
- Dry feeds are powdered mixes fed in open feeders outdoors.
Bees prefer real pollen, and in many studies colonies raise more brood on it than on substitutes, though substitutes can still support brood in a shortage. Quality varies widely among products. Because composition, labelling and regulations differ, buy from reputable suppliers and follow the label.
When feeding patties makes sense
Patties help when natural pollen is truly short and the colony is ready to raise brood:
- Late winter to early spring, when queens start laying before pollen sources open. Feeding patties can accelerate build-up, which helps to prepare colonies for early flows or pollination.
- Dearth periods in summer or fall, when brood rearing stalls for lack of pollen.
- Splits and nucs that need support to build up.
- Commercial pollination operations that need strong colonies by a specific date.
They are often unnecessary when natural pollen is plentiful. A colony rearing brood well on natural forage does not need supplements, and feeding patties too early can push a colony into brood rearing during a cold snap, which can stress it. Time feeding to your local pollen availability. Consult Late Winter: Stimulating Early Brood Rearing and Spring Feeding: Syrup Ratios and Methods.
When to skip patties
- If pollen is already coming in, which you can see as bees with pollen loads at the entrance.
- If the colony is queenless, weak or diseased, since patties will not fix those problems.
- If small hive beetles are active in your area; see Small Hive Beetle (SHB): Identification and Control.
- If it is too cold for bees to access the patties.
- If you plan to sell honey from supers on the hive; remove supers and keep supplements out of them.
Do not use patties as a replacement for good management. A colony lacking pollen may lack forage, may have a poor queen, or may have a mite problem.
How to feed patties
- Choose a patty from a reputable supplier, and check the label and expiry.
- Use small amounts. Start with a small patty, often a few ounces to a pound, depending on the colony size and the product's directions.
- Place it on the top bars, directly above the brood nest, often between wax paper or plastic sheets, with the edges cut or torn so bees can access it.
- Use a spacer. An empty rim or shim creates room above the frames so the cover closes.
- Check regularly. Replace patties when they are eaten, and remove old or mouldy ones.
- Stop when natural pollen arrives or when the colony stops eating it.
Do not feed more than the bees can consume within a couple of weeks; excess patty is a magnet for beetles, mice and mould.
Dry pollen substitutes
Dry feeds are powdered mixes offered in open containers away from the apiary. They are used by some commercial keepers in warm climates. Drawbacks include attracting bees from other colonies, dust, rain damage, and wasteful feeding. Many hobbyists prefer patties inside the hive. Some products are wet mixed with syrup; follow label instructions.
Pests, mould and storage
- Small hive beetles love patties. Use small patties, place them on top of frames, and remove leftovers. Do not leave patties in warm, humid hives.
- Mice may chew patties in winter hives; see Mouse Guards and Entrance Reducers.
- Storage: keep patties frozen or cool, sealed, and use before the expiry. Thaw before use. Mouldy patties should be discarded.
- Ants and wasps: keep spills cleaned up.
Making your own
Some beekeepers mix their own patties from sugar, protein powder and yeast. There are many recipes online, but ingredients matter: poor protein sources can harm bees, and homemade mixes can attract pests or spoil. Without testing, it is hard to know if a recipe is nutritionally complete. If you choose to make your own, use food-grade ingredients and follow tested formulations from an extension service or reputable bee-science source. When in doubt, buy a commercial product.
Better than patties: forage
The best protein source is natural pollen from diverse flowers. Plant pollen-rich species near your apiary, avoid mowing flowering plants too early, and work with neighbours. A varied landscape supports brood rearing through the season. See Pollen Collection: Colors and Sources for how bees gather and use it, and Bee Pollen: Collection and Preservation if you are curious about pollen as a product. Consider also how pollen use fits with your season and your hive type, as discussed in Feeding Equipment: Boardman, Top, and Frame Feeders.
Reading your colony before you feed
Before buying anything, look at the evidence. Check whether foragers are returning with pollen loads, which appear as coloured balls on their hind legs, and whether open brood and eggs are present. Look at frames for stored bee bread, the fermented pollen packed around the brood nest; a colony with plenty of it is not in urgent need. Compare the amount of brood with the colony's size. If brood is shrinking while the weather and forage are poor, a patty may help, but if the queen is failing, no supplement will fix that. See Reading Frames: Brood, Honey, Pollen, and Empty Comb for what to look for.
Keep records of when natural pollen arrives in your area each year, such as early maples, willows or other local species, and use those dates to plan future feeding. Over a few seasons you will learn whether supplement ever pays for itself in your yard.
FAQ
Do bees need pollen patties?
Not usually; bees thrive on natural pollen when it is available, and patties are best seen as a short-term supplement during shortages.
Will pollen patties attract small hive beetles?
They can, since beetles are drawn to the moist, protein-rich patties, so use small patties, remove leftovers, and avoid feeding them in warm, humid conditions where beetles are active.
Are pollen substitutes as good as real pollen?
Real pollen usually supports better brood rearing, but good-quality substitutes can help colonies through shortages when natural pollen is unavailable.