Every beekeeper who keeps bees long enough opens a hive in January or February and finds a small cluster beside empty comb. Starvation is the most preventable cause of winter loss, and emergency feeding is the intervention that can turn a dying colony around. The usual tools are fondant, candy boards, sugar bricks and the Mountain Camp method, which uses dry sugar on newspaper. This article explains how to recognise hunger, when emergency feeding is worthwhile, how to make and place each type of feed, and how to avoid adding moisture or disturbing the cluster more than necessary.
Recognising a hungry colony
The most reliable sign is weight. Heft hives regularly through winter and compare to the fall weight. A hive that feels like an empty box is almost out of food. At the entrance, a silent hive on a mild day, or one with bees crawling out and dying, may indicate starvation. If you open the top, look for bees head-first in empty cells and no capped honey near the cluster.
Remember that colonies often starve with honey elsewhere in the hive. In cold snaps the cluster cannot move sideways to reach it. Use the information from Winter Cluster Dynamics: Heat Generation and Survival to see why this happens. Because brood rearing increases consumption in late winter, check hives more often then; see Late Winter: Stimulating Early Brood Rearing.
When is emergency feeding worthwhile?
If bees are still alive and moving, feed. A colony that has fewer than about a pound of honey left may die within days. Even a small cluster can recover if it has food and a living queen. If the cluster is dead, there is no point, and you should instead plan to salvage equipment and learn from it; see What to Do If Your Bees Die: Lessons Learned.
Don't feed liquid syrup in freezing weather. Bees cannot dry it, and the moisture can chill them. Use solid feeds that bees can reach without breaking cluster. Even in emergencies, aim to work quickly and on the warmest part of the day. A brief opening to place feed is better than letting the colony starve, but think before you open.
Fondant
Fondant is a smooth, firm sugar paste. You can buy bakers' fondant or make it from sugar and water, boiling to a specific temperature. Cooking it requires care, since the mixture is hot and can burn skin. Avoid additives and use only plain white sugar. Cool fondant should be firm enough to hold its shape but soft enough for bees to scrape.
To use it, place slabs directly above the cluster on the top bars, with a spacer or shim around them to keep the cover from squashing the feed. Wrap it in wax paper or put it in a plastic container with the open side down. Bees will take it over days or weeks. See Fondant and Candy Boards for detailed recipes and construction.
Candy boards
A candy board is a shallow wooden frame with a screen or slot on the bottom and a block of hard sugar candy cast inside. It sits on top of the hive in place of the inner cover, giving bees access to food directly above the cluster, and the board is insulating. You can build one or buy it ready-made. The candy must be hard enough to not drip, which usually means cooking sugar to a particular temperature.
Candy boards are best installed in the fall as insurance, but they can be added in winter as an emergency measure. Because they also hold in warmth and absorb moisture, they are popular in cold climates. Make sure there is an upper vent and an entrance for ventilation. Replace boards as the candy is consumed. Build quality matters: warped boards leak heat.
The Mountain Camp method
The Mountain Camp method uses plain dry sugar spread on a sheet of newspaper placed on the top bars, with a shim to make room. The bees can access dry sugar and take moisture from the cluster to dissolve it. It is cheap and requires no cooking. Place the newspaper over the top bars, pour a couple of pounds of granulated sugar on it, shape it into a mound, and cover with a shim and the lid.
It works best in dry conditions. In very dry hives bees may struggle to use dry sugar, and in damp hives sugar can cake and mould. Place the sugar close to the cluster, and check on it after a few weeks. It is a stopgap more than a complete solution, but in an emergency it can bridge a gap until the next warm day.
Comparing emergency feeds
| Feed | Cost and effort | Moisture | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fondant slab | Moderate, cooking or buying | Low | Quick fix on top bars |
| Candy board | Higher up front, reusable | Absorbs moisture | Fall insurance or winter |
| Mountain Camp | Cheapest, no cooking | Needs hive humidity | Emergency stopgap |
| Sugar bricks | Moderate | Low | Alternative to fondant |
Whichever you choose, place feed above the cluster, close to the bees, and record the date. Following the feed, monitor the hive weekly by hefting and observing. If the colony continues to lose weight, add more.
Avoiding mistakes
Don't open hives in freezing temperatures longer than necessary. Don't pour liquid syrup on a cold cluster. Don't feed honey of unknown source, since it can carry disease. Don't use brown sugar or raw sugar, and don't use additives you cannot verify. Keep the feed within reach of the cluster.
After feeding, ensure that ventilation is good, since the cluster is working and producing moisture. Finally, learn from the emergency. Was the colony light in fall? Did it begin brood rearing early? Did you leave too little honey? Adjust your fall feeding and harvest plans; see Fall Feeding: 2:1 Syrup and Fondant and Winter Preparation: The Complete Checklist.
Placing feed without wrecking the cluster
The technique matters as much as the feed itself. Choose the warmest part of a mild day, ideally above 40-45°F (4-7°C), prepare everything in advance, and lift only the outer cover and inner cover. Have the fondant or board ready to place, with shims in position, so the hive is open for under a minute. Do not remove frames. If the cluster is below the top bars, you may need to place the feed over the gap where bees are visible, and a small amount of smoke is not necessary.
Position the feed directly over the visible bees. If the cluster is on the side of the box, place the feed on that side. Pile some insulation, such as a folded cloth or a piece of foam, over the feed to reduce heat loss, and make sure the upper vent still works. If the colony has moved to a lower box, shift the feed lower, even if it requires removing an upper box carefully. In most cases a colony that has started to starve will still be alive near the top.
Check back within a week to see whether the feed is being taken. Bees on the feed, or crumbs of sugar below the board, are encouraging signs. If untouched after two weeks, assess whether the colony is alive. A small amount of feed taken is better than none, and you should replace it before it runs out.
FAQ
Can I give bees syrup in winter?
Not in freezing weather. Bees cannot evaporate the water and may chill. Use fondant, a candy board or dry sugar instead.
What is the Mountain Camp method?
It is a way of feeding dry sugar on newspaper laid over the top bars. The bees use moisture in the hive to dissolve it. It is cheap, but works best when the hive is not too dry.
How can I prevent starvation next year?
Make sure colonies go into winter heavy by feeding in fall, leave enough honey at harvest and heft hives regularly through winter.