A pail feeder, also called a bucket feeder, is a food-grade pail with a handful of tiny holes in the lid, turned upside-down over the hive's inner cover hole so bees can lick syrup as it seeps out. It is one of the cheapest, largest-capacity and least disruptive feeders. It is not perfect: it needs extra space on the hive, it can drip, and it must be set up carefully. This article covers how the feeder works, how to make or buy one, how to install it, how to feed safely, and the problems to avoid. I have built dozens of these and have the sticky boots to prove it.
How a pail feeder works
Syrup is poured into a lidded pail, and the lid is perforated with small holes. When you invert the pail over the inner cover hole, atmospheric pressure and surface tension hold the syrup in. Bees climb up, put their tongues to the holes, and take syrup as they need it. As syrup leaves, air bubbles in and the flow continues.
Because the feeder sits over the cluster, bees can feed without leaving the warm area. That makes pails good for cool weather, though not for freezing temperatures where syrup would chill or freeze. Capacity is typically one to five gallons, so you can feed a lot at once.
Buying or making a pail feeder
You can buy a pail with a pre-drilled lid or make your own. DIY is easy:
- Choose a pail. Use a new or thoroughly cleaned food-grade bucket with a tight lid. Never reuse a container that held chemicals, paint, or non-food products.
- Drill holes. In the lid, drill four to ten small holes, around 1/16 inch (about 1.5 mm), centred or near the middle. Drill from the inside outward to avoid burrs.
- Test it. Fill with water, invert it over a sink, and check that drips are slow or stop. If it pours, the holes are too large.
- Sand and clean. Remove plastic burrs and wash the pail.
Many commercial pails come with the right hole size, which saves trial and error. Check the lid seals well.
Installing the feeder
- Prepare the hive. Remove the outer cover and check that the inner cover hole is unobstructed.
- Add an empty box. Place an empty deep or medium super around the pail, so the roof can close.
- Fill the pail. Fill it near the hive, tighten the lid and invert it over a tray so any initial drip is caught.
- Set it on the hole. Place the pail upside-down on the inner cover hole, with a shim if the holes sit against the cover.
- Cover. Replace the outer cover, making sure there are no gaps for robbers.
- Check. Look in a day or two to see whether bees are taking syrup and whether the pail leaks.
Some beekeepers place the pail directly on top of the frames, over a small gap. That works in warm weather but may crush bees if you are not careful.
Syrup, volume and timing
Common ratios are about 1:1 sugar to water in spring and 2:1 in fall, measured by weight or by volume according to local practice. Use plain white granulated sugar, not other sweeteners, and follow current guidance from your state beekeeping association or extension office. Warm water dissolves sugar faster, but do not boil or caramelise it. Let syrup cool before feeding.
Feed in the evening, and do not feed when supers are on. A strong colony can empty a gallon pail in days during a dearth or in fall, so check often. Small colonies can take too much and fill the brood nest with syrup, leaving no room for the queen, so give modest amounts and watch.
For when to feed, see Spring Feeding: Syrup Ratios and Methods, Summer Feeding: When Nectar Stops and Fall Feeding: 2:1 Syrup and Fondant.
Preventing leaks and robbing
- Test before use. Invert the pail over a sink; if it drips steadily, use a tighter lid or smaller holes.
- Keep the inner cover level. A tilted cover causes drips.
- Seal the box. Close gaps so robbers cannot get in; see Robbing Screens: Installation and Use.
- Do not overfill. A pail slightly under-full leaks less.
- Change the pail regularly. Syrup that stands for weeks can ferment.
If you see robbing, stop feeding, reduce the entrance, and reduce disturbance. See Robbing Behavior: Prevention and Response.
Advantages
- Large capacity, so fewer visits.
- Feeds inside the hive, which reduces robbing compared with entrance feeders.
- Low cost and easy to improvise.
- Easy to clean and reuse.
- Minimal disturbance, because the cluster stays closed.
Disadvantages
- Needs an extra box and a flat inner cover, adding height.
- Can leak and soak the hive if the lid fails.
- Hard to see how much remains without lifting the cover.
- Not suitable for freezing weather.
- Might encourage bees to build burr comb into the empty space; keep the gap tidy.
Cleaning and storage
Rinse the pail after each use and scrub off dried syrup with warm water. Do not use detergent residues; rinse well. Dry thoroughly before storing, with the lid off, to prevent mould. Store the pail in a clean, pest-free place. Check the holes for clogging, and replace the pail if the plastic cracks. For other feeding systems, see Feeding Equipment: Boardman, Top, and Frame Feeders and Entrance Feeders vs. In-Hive Feeders.
Troubleshooting a pail feeder
It pours instead of seeping. Holes are too big, the lid is not sealing, or the pail is warped. Replace the lid or reduce the number of holes, and test with water first.
Bees ignore it. Check that the pail sits directly over the inner cover hole and that bees can reach the holes. If the gap is too wide, bees may not climb to it; add a shim. Cold weather, a strong natural flow or an unhealthy colony can also stop feeding.
Comb builds in the empty box. Bees often fill space above the frames with burr comb. Keep the gap to only what the pail needs, and scrape comb at each visit.
Ants or wasps are visiting. Look for drips on the outside of the pail or the box. Wipe spills and consider a moat or other ant barrier on the stand.
Syrup smells sour. Fermentation means it sat too long or too warm. Empty it, wash the pail and refill with fresh, smaller amounts. Compare options in Feeding Equipment: Boardman, Top, and Frame Feeders if you find pails too fiddly.
FAQ
How big should the holes be in a pail feeder lid?
Very small, roughly 1/16 inch (about 1.5 mm), so syrup is held in by surface tension and only seeps when bees lick it; test with water before use.
Can I use any bucket as a feeder?
Use only a clean, food-grade bucket that has never held chemicals, paint or non-food products, and make sure the lid seals well.
Can I use a pail feeder in winter?
Generally not in freezing weather, since syrup can chill the cluster or freeze; use fondant or a candy board instead.