In every apiary, colonies develop at different speeds. By mid-spring, one hive may be bursting with brood while its neighbour struggles. Equalizing is the practice of redistributing resources, mainly frames of capped brood with adhering bees, from strong colonies to weak ones so that all are productive by the time the main flow arrives. Done well, it reduces swarming in the donors, improves the weak colonies and increases overall honey production. This article explains why to equalise, how to do it safely, and what to watch for.
Why equalise
A colony that is too small to use the flow produces little honey, and one that is too strong may swarm. Equalizing aims at a middle path: moving brood from colonies on the verge of swarming to colonies that can use it. This keeps strong colonies under control, boosts weak ones, and results in more colonies reaching peak population on time. It is a skilful use of the apiary as a single system.
Timing matters. You want the frames of brood to hatch into workers by the time the flow starts, so you should do this about four to six weeks before the main flow. Too early, and the weak colony may be unable to keep the brood warm. Too late, and the workers emerge after the flow is over. See Honey Flow Management: When to Super for how to count back from the flow.
Choosing donors and recipients
Donors should be strong, disease-free colonies, with a good queen and plenty of capped brood. Recipients should be queenright and healthy but small. Don't use equalizing to prop up colonies with disease, queen problems or heavy mite loads. In such cases, it can spread problems or waste resources. Evaluate the colonies carefully first; see Managing Strong vs. Weak Colonies.
Check for signs of disease and mites in the donor before moving any brood. Examine capped brood for sunken cappings, holes or odd smells. If anything is suspicious, do not move frames. Contact your state apiarist or local expert. See American Foulbrood (AFB): Identification and Response and European Foulbrood (EFB): Stress-Related Disease for symptoms.
How to move brood
Choose a warm, calm day when the weather is stable. Open the donor colony and select one or two frames of capped brood, with the bees adhering. Take care not to move the queen; find her first and set her aside in the donor box, or check each frame carefully. Brush off excess bees if there is any risk, but leave enough nurse bees to cover the brood.
Place the frames in the recipient colony, next to the brood nest and between frames of existing brood, or at the edge of the nest if the weather is cool. Fill the gap in the donor with drawn comb or foundation, so that the queen has room to lay. Avoid giving more than the recipient can cover. A general rule is not to add more brood than the colony can cover with bees; one or two frames at a time is typical.
Swapping hive positions
An alternative method is to swap the positions of a strong and a weak hive. Foragers from the strong colony return to the old location and join the weak colony in its new place, instantly boosting its force. The strong colony gets the weak one's smaller force. This method works best when the weather is good and when foragers are flying. It can give a quick population boost, but it may upset the strong colony and cause temporary loss of foragers.
Use this method with caution. Be sure that both colonies are healthy and avoid doing it when robbing is likely. Because the swap transfers foragers and any mite or disease load with them, only use it when both colonies are known to be healthy. This approach is less common than moving brood.
Monitoring the results
After equalizing, check both colonies a week later. In the donor, check for queen cells and ensure the queen has laid in the new comb. In the recipient, make sure the brood is being cared for, and that the queen is still laying. Adjust feed and space as needed. If the recipient is still weak, consider combining it with another colony; see Combining Weak Colonies: Newspaper Method.
Keep records of what you moved and when. Track whether donors still swarm and whether recipients grow as expected. Note the effect on honey production at the end of the season. This kind of record-keeping helps you refine your approach each year; see Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs.
A note on timing and weather
Brood is fragile, and a frame carried across the yard on a cold day can chill within minutes. Do equalizing only when the air temperature is comfortably in the sixties Fahrenheit, with no wind, and carry frames in a closed spare box so they stay warm. Work from one hive to the next quickly, and avoid leaving frames uncovered. If a cold snap follows, reduce entrances and be ready to feed the recipient, because extra brood means extra mouths. Keep an eye on stores in the recipient for the following two weeks.
Risks and limits
Equalizing is not a cure-all. If a weak colony is weak for reasons other than strength, such as disease, a failing queen or poor location, adding brood will not fix it. It can also delay your ability to identify poor queens. Moving brood between colonies can spread disease, and you should never move brood from a colony with symptoms.
There is also a limit to how much a donor can give. Taking too many frames can set back a strong colony and reduce its honey crop. Think about the overall balance and the time left before the flow. For beekeepers aiming at swarm control, combine equalizing with other methods, as explained in Swarm Season: Prevention and Management, and consider splitting when the colony remains crowded.
Equalizing and swarm control together
Because equalizing removes brood from the strongest colonies, it doubles as a swarm-control measure. A colony that has just lost two frames of capped brood has fewer young bees to feel crowded and more empty comb for the queen, so the urge to build queen cells fades for a couple of weeks. Beekeepers with many hives often schedule equalizing at the same visit as their weekly swarm checks, so they open each strong colony only once. If a donor already has capped queen cells, equalizing alone will not stop the swarm and you should split it instead.
A simple equalizing routine
- Evaluate all colonies and rank them by strength.
- Check donors for disease and mites.
- Select two to four weeks before the flow minus emerging time.
- Move one or two frames of capped brood to a weaker colony.
- Replace frames in the donor with drawn comb.
- Inspect in a week to confirm acceptance.
- Record outcomes.
FAQ
When should I equalize colonies?
In mid-spring, four to six weeks before the main flow, so the transferred brood emerges in time to forage.
How much brood should I move?
One or two frames of capped brood with adhering bees at a time, and no more than the recipient can cover and keep warm.
Is it safe to move brood between colonies?
Only if both colonies are healthy. Do not move brood from colonies with disease symptoms or heavy mite loads, since it can spread the problem.