A laying worker colony is a hive that has been queenless for so long that some workers' ovaries have developed and they have begun laying eggs. Because workers cannot mate, every egg they lay is unfertilized and develops into a drone, so the colony produces only drones and is doomed unless the beekeeper intervenes. Laying workers are one of the harder problems in beekeeping to solve, because they resist new queens and cannot be fixed by simply adding one. This article explains the biology, how to diagnose the condition and which recovery methods work.
The Biology of Laying Workers
Worker bees are female and have functional ovaries, but under normal conditions those ovaries remain undeveloped. Queen mandibular pheromone and signals from open brood suppress ovary activation in the workers. In a queenright colony, the vast majority of workers never lay eggs.
When a colony loses its queen and fails to raise a replacement, those signals fade. After a few weeks, some workers begin to activate their ovaries. Research suggests a small fraction of the colony's workers become egg layers, often those that have spent time near brood and have good nutrition. See the queen and pheromones and communication.
Workers cannot mate, because their reproductive tract is not built for it, so they lay unfertilized eggs. In honey bees, unfertilized eggs become males. The haplodiploid system means that fertilized eggs become females and unfertilized become males. See honey bee genetics. A colony of laying workers therefore produces drones only, and as the worker population ages and dies, the colony shrinks and collapses.
How Laying Workers Develop
Development usually takes about three to four weeks, perhaps longer, after a colony becomes hopelessly queenless. Colonies that are truly queenless but still have open brood suppress worker ovary development for longer, because brood pheromones help restrain workers. Once the last brood has emerged, suppression lifts quickly.
Colonies that were queenless in spring or summer, and that did not have a chance to raise a queen, are the likeliest to develop laying workers. Causes include a failed mating flight, a queen killed during inspection, a failed introduction, or a colony with no young larvae to raise a new queen from. See queenlessness.
Laying workers appear more often in some stocks than others, and in colonies with large populations of young, well-fed nurses. A strong colony can reach laying worker status quickly. A weak colony may dwindle before the condition emerges.
Diagnosing a Laying Worker Colony
Laying workers produce a recognizable pattern, although it can be confused with a failing queen.
- Multiple eggs per cell. Workers often lay several eggs in one cell, sometimes up to a dozen or more, and they lay on the walls rather than the base.
- Irregular placement. Eggs sit off-center or on the cell sides, in contrast to a queen's single egg placed upright at the base.
- Scattered, spotty brood. The pattern is irregular, with drone-sized capped cells in worker comb.
- Bullet-shaped cappings. Drone brood in worker cells protrudes from the surface in a domed pattern, known as "bullet brood" or "hump-backed" brood.
- No queen and no queen cells. Check carefully for queens, as some mated queens are present but failing.
- Behavior. The colony may be defensive, noisy and sometimes aggressive, and it may reject a new queen.
It is important to distinguish laying workers from a drone-laying queen. A queen laying only unfertilized eggs also produces bullet brood, but her eggs are single, centered in the cells and appear in a compact pattern. If you find a queen and all the eggs are single and centered, the problem is the queen. See evaluating queen performance.
Why New Queens Are Usually Rejected
The simplest idea, to add a queen, almost always fails. Laying workers bring their own pheromone profile, and their presence changes how the colony responds to a stranger. Workers often kill or ball an introduced queen, even when she is caged. In effect, the colony has accepted a state where it lacks a queen yet carries its own reproductive workers.
Some beekeepers report success with a queen introduced in a protective cage, with slow release over many days, and sometimes after giving the colony brood. Results are inconsistent. Mated queens are expensive and should not be wasted in colonies with a high rate of rejection.
The better strategy is to resolve the laying worker problem first, then introduce a queen in a way that improves acceptance. See queen introduction: direct vs. cage methods and queen acceptance: factors and failures.
Recovery Methods That Work
Beekeepers use several approaches. Choose based on colony size, season and your resources.
- Combine with a queenright colony. This is the most reliable method. Place a sheet of newspaper on top of a strong queenright colony, set the laying worker box above it, and let the bees chew through. The queen's pheromone typically takes over, and the laying workers merge into the stronger colony. Some beekeepers shake out the laying workers away from the hive first.
- Add frames of open brood. Giving young brood from a healthy colony every week or so for a few weeks helps suppress ovary development and supplies larvae for the colony to raise queens from. It may not succeed if too many workers have active ovaries.
- Shake out and relocate. Move the hive some distance away, shake all bees out in the grass and let the foragers return to the original stand. Laying workers, with heavy ovaries, may not fly well and often do not return. The returning bees can then receive a queen or brood. This is time-consuming and has mixed results.
- Disband the colony. If the colony is small, old or in a poor season, combine or disperse the bees. Put the equipment aside and save the stores.
Whichever you choose, document the event and learn from it. See queen introduction if you intend to replace the queen after cleanup.
Preventing Laying Workers
Prevention is much easier than cure. Inspect new colonies and splits for eggs within a week or two of introducing a queen or cell. If a colony is queenless, act promptly, preferably within two weeks, by supplying a mated queen or a frame of eggs and young larvae for the colony to rear its own.
Keep notes on which colonies have been queenless and when. Do not leave a queenless colony without brood for more than three weeks if you can help it. Use the "test frame" method: add a frame of eggs and young larvae from another colony, and check after several days for queen cells. If the bees draw cells, the colony still recognizes its queenless state and can be saved. If they do not, laying workers may already be present.
Prompt requeening or merger before ovaries activate is the surest approach. See queen introduction for proven techniques.
Why Drone-Only Colonies Fail
A laying worker colony loses ground steadily because no new workers are produced. The workers that remain age and die within weeks, and the population declines. Meanwhile, the drones produced consume resources and offer no benefit to the colony. See drone bees.
The colony also attracts pests. Wax moths, small hive beetles and robbers exploit declining colonies, and a laying worker colony is often an easy target. If left untouched, the hive may be robbed out, and disease may spread to neighbors.
For this reason, do not hesitate. Once laying workers are confirmed, choose a remedy within a day or two. The colony's chances of recovery drop as the proportion of workers with developed ovaries grows. A colony saved early may recover with a combination and a new queen. A colony left for months usually cannot.
FAQ
Can laying workers produce a new queen?
No. Laying workers produce only unfertilized eggs, which develop into drones, and the colony cannot raise a queen from drone brood. A queen can be raised only from a fertilized egg or young female larva given by the beekeeper.
How can I tell laying workers from a drone-laying queen?
Laying workers lay several eggs in a cell, often on the cell wall, with no queen present, while a drone-laying queen lays one centered egg per cell. Confirm by finding the queen or by examining the eggs.
Is a laying worker colony worth saving?
Often the best use of the effort is combining the bees with a strong queenright colony, since this recovers the workers and equipment. Direct requeening of a laying worker hive has a low success rate.