Introducing a new queen to a colony is one of the most failure-prone tasks in beekeeping. Workers can recognize the smell and behavior of a stranger and may ball her, sting her or ignore her until she disappears. Success comes from understanding why bees accept or reject a queen, then using a method that gives them time to adjust. The two basic approaches are direct release and cage introduction, with several variations. This article compares them, explains preparation, walks through the steps, and covers the problems that cause failure.
Why bees reject a new queen
A colony recognizes its queen by pheromones and behavior. A queenless colony quickly starts to change: brood pheromone declines, nurses begin building emergency cells, and some workers may even begin laying. A new queen introduced into this mix is seen as an outsider. If she smells wrong, acts nervously, or arrives while the colony still has a queen, workers may attack.
Acceptance is a matter of timing and stress. Colonies that have been queenless for a short time, such as a day, tend to accept readily. Colonies that have been queenless for a long time may have laying workers and can be hostile. Colonies with emergency cells in progress may not accept a queen until those cells are removed. See Queenlessness: Signs and Timing for how queenless colonies behave, and Queen Acceptance: Factors and Failures for the factors behind success or failure.
Preparing the colony
Before introducing, prepare the colony.
- Remove the old queen. Do this carefully, and be sure she is gone. Check the whole hive.
- Wait. A gap of about 24 hours between removal and introduction is common, which lets the colony feel the loss but not so long that workers start laying.
- Remove emergency cells. Inspect every frame and destroy cells, because bees with a cell in progress will not accept a new queen as readily.
- Reduce the colony space. A cramped colony with few frames may accept more readily than one with a lot of empty space.
- Check for laying workers. If you see multiple eggs per cell or drone brood in worker cells, the colony needs special handling, such as merging.
Weather and forage also matter. Introduce queens in a strong flow, or feed the colony syrup, because bees in a dearth are more irritable. Avoid introducing during robbing or unsettled weather.
Cage introduction
The most reliable approach for a purchased queen is indirect introduction, using the cage she arrives in. The cage has a candy plug at one end that bees slowly eat through, releasing the queen after a few days.
- Remove the old queen and wait the preparation period.
- Leave the queen in her shipping cage, with the attendants removed if the supplier advises it, to avoid introducing foreign bees.
- Remove any cork or plastic plug covering the candy end, leaving the candy exposed. Do not release the queen directly.
- Place the cage between two frames of brood, candy end facing up or tilted so dead bees can fall away, with the screen accessible to workers.
- Close the hive and leave it alone for several days.
- Check after about three to five days, and see whether the queen has been released. Look for workers calmly feeding her.
During this time, workers feed and groom her through the screen, and her scent spreads through the hive. By the time the candy is eaten, the colony is accustomed to her. If workers cluster aggressively on the cage and bite the screen, delay release and keep her caged for a few more days. More detail is in Introducing a New Queen to a Queenright Colony for cases where the old queen has not been removed.
Direct release
Direct release means placing the queen into the colony without a cage. It is faster but riskier. It works best with a colony that has been queenless for a short period, with a young, freshly mated queen and with a calm, strong colony in a flow.
Some beekeepers use direct release with a small amount of smoke or a spritz of sugar syrup, to mask the queen's scent. Others place the queen on the frame edge and watch. If workers show aggression, such as grabbing or balling, remove her immediately. Direct release is more often used by experienced beekeepers who can intervene quickly. For most, cage introduction is safer, particularly for expensive or valuable queens.
Comparing the methods
| Method | Speed | Risk | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cage with candy plug | Slow, three to five days | Low | Purchased queens, most situations |
| Direct release | Immediate | Higher | Small colonies, experienced beekeepers |
| Push-in cage over comb | Moderate | Low to moderate | Queens that are laying, where eggs are available |
| Newspaper combine | Slow, a few days | Low | Introducing to a queenright colony |
| Ripe cell | Immediate | Low | Raising your own queens, see Cell Banking and Transport |
Choose according to the situation. For purchased queens, use the cage method unless the supplier gives different instructions. For virgin queens, a cage is essential, because virgins are fast and fragile.
After introduction
Once the queen is released, give the colony a week before checking carefully. Opening the hive too soon can disturb her and trigger balling. When you inspect, look for eggs, the queen herself, and calm worker behavior. Eggs usually appear within a few days of release, but a queen that has been in a cage may start laying slowly.
If the colony has built queen cells, the queen may have been rejected. Check whether she is alive. If dead, the colony may need a ripe cell, a frame of eggs or another queen. Check for laying workers. If the new queen disappeared without a trace, consider whether the colony was truly queenless at introduction, or whether a virgin or an old queen was missed.
Keep the colony strong, feed it if needed, and avoid disturbances. For marking, see Marking and Tracking Queens.
Troubleshooting
- Bees ball the cage. Delay release, and move the cage to a calmer part of the hive.
- Queen released but vanished. The colony may have killed her. Check for dead queen on the bottom board, and for cells.
- Colony with laying workers. Introduction rarely works. Merge with a queenright colony or shake out the bees.
- Queen not laying. She may need more time, or may be poorly mated. Check after two weeks.
- Old queen still present. If you missed her, the new queen will be killed. Search carefully, and see Finding the Queen: Tips for Beginners.
FAQ
How long should a queen stay in her cage?
Usually three to five days, long enough for workers to get used to her scent, and she is released when the bees have eaten through the candy plug and are treating her calmly.
Can I put a new queen straight into a queenless hive?
Direct release can work for a short-term queenless colony and a calm, strong hive, but cage introduction is safer for most situations, particularly with purchased or valuable queens.
Why did my colony kill a new queen?
Common reasons include a missed old queen, emergency cells, laying workers, a weak flow with stressed bees, or a release made too early, so prepare the colony and use a cage to reduce risk.