A colony that survives winter in good condition is the foundation of every honey crop and every queen-rearing season, and winter survival is among the most valuable and most difficult traits to select. Winter loss depends on mites, nutrition, weather, queen age and management as much as on genes. A breeder who wants a line that winters well must separate genetics from circumstances and gather data across several winters. This article explains what makes colonies winter well, how to measure it, how to select breeders and how to keep management from masking genetic differences.
What winter success includes
Winter success is more than "alive in spring." A colony that is alive but weak, with a failing queen and low stores, is not a good breeder. Useful components include:
- Survival through the cold period.
- Spring strength measured in frames of bees and brood at a set date.
- Stores use, meaning how much honey the colony consumed.
- Queen survival, since supersedure in winter or spring signals a weakness.
- Low disease and mite load at the time of going into winter and coming out.
- Absence of dysentery or other winter-related problems.
For beekeepers in cold climates the winter cluster is central; see Winter Cluster Dynamics: Heat Generation and Survival. In mild climates, winter loss is more often a matter of dearth, pests or poor brood-rearing.
Genetic factors
Several traits influence overwintering.
- Brood-rearing pattern. Colonies that reduce brood in autumn and restart at the right time in late winter use fewer stores and avoid raising brood during a dearth. Stocks differ in this pattern; see Carniolan Bees: Winter Hardiness and Gentleness and Russian Honey Bees: Varroa Resistance for examples.
- Cluster behavior. Compact, well-regulated clusters conserve energy.
- Winter-bee quality. The long-lived winter bees must be reared with enough nutrition and low virus load; see Varroa Destructor: The Beekeeper's Primary Enemy for why mites in fall reduce winter bee quality.
- Stores efficiency. Colonies that use less honey to survive the same winter are advantageous.
- Disease tolerance against Nosema and viruses; see Nosema apis and Nosema ceranae.
Stocks adapted to cold regions often shut down brood rearing earlier and restart later than those from mild climates. These differences are partly genetic, so local selection matters.
Measuring overwintering fairly
To compare lines you need standard conditions.
- Equalize in fall. Start winter with colonies of similar size, stores and queen age; record frames of bees and weight.
- Standardize management. Use the same wrapping, ventilation, feeding and mite control across test colonies; see Preparing Your Hive for Winter: First-Year Edition and Winter Preparation: The Complete Checklist.
- Check mite counts. Treat mites and record counts before winter; a heavily infested colony in fall will fail regardless of genes.
- Weigh or heft. Record hive weight in late fall and again in late winter to estimate stores use.
- Assess in spring. Count frames of bees and brood, and note queen status.
- Repeat for several winters. One mild winter may hide weak lines; one severe winter may punish good ones.
Hive scales or careful weighing give data without opening colonies in cold weather. Do not open a winter cluster in cold weather just to count.
Separating genetics from management
Several factors can fool you.
- Queen age. Young queens winter better; compare queens of the same age.
- Mites. A colony that was treated late may die for reasons unrelated to its genes.
- Position. Colonies in windy or shaded spots do worse. Randomize placement across yards.
- Feeding. Colonies fed more heavily in fall may look better; give all test colonies the same feeding.
- Splits and nucs. Late-season nucs behave differently from full colonies; do not mix them in the same comparison.
Record all of these. See Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs. If you cannot control a factor, record it so you can interpret results later.
Selecting breeders
Choose breeders from colonies that:
- Survived with good spring strength in multiple winters.
- Used stores moderately.
- Had acceptable mite loads and disease status.
- Showed good temperament and honey production; see Breeding Stock Selection: Field Evaluation.
Raise daughters from these breeders, and test the daughters in several yards. Evaluate progeny over at least two winters; see Progeny Testing Queens. A queen whose daughters winter well in multiple yards is more valuable than a single surviving colony. Sell or use daughters only after testing.
The role of local adaptation
Bees selected in a given climate often winter better there than imports. Northern breeders commonly select from colonies that survive long, cold winters, and southern breeders select for tolerance of heat, dearth and different pests. If you buy queens from far away, test them in your yards; the line may need adjustment. See Local and Feral Bees: Survivor Stock and Subspecies and Races: Italian, Carniolan, Russian, Caucasian.
Interaction with management
Beekeeping decisions in summer and fall have large effects on overwintering. Good forage, low mite loads in August, adequate stores and prompt requeening of failing queens improve survival more than any single gene. For breeders, that means two things. First, test your stock under your standard management, not an idealized one. Second, avoid blaming genetics for what is a management failure. Check fall inspections; see Fall Inspections: What to Check. For colony protection practices see Winterizing Hives: Insulation and Ventilation.
Winter feeding and emergencies
Colonies can starve in winter even if they looked heavy in fall, especially in a warm spell followed by cold. Check weight periodically and be ready to give emergency feed; see Emergency Winter Feeding: Candy Boards and Mountain Camp. Breeding colonies should be prioritized for rescue so you do not lose valuable lines. Record any emergency feeding, since colonies that need rescue are poor candidates for breeding.
A simple winter scorecard
Give each colony a short scorecard at the late-winter or early-spring check. Record whether it is alive, the number of frames covered by bees on a cool but flyable day, whether there is brood and of what extent, the amount of remaining stores, the presence of dysentery streaking on the hive front and whether the original queen is still present. Score each item from zero to three and total it. Repeat each year and add the totals for a colony's daughters. This produces a number you can rank without relying on memory, and it lets you notice colonies that survive by luck, such as those that scraped through on emergency feed, versus those that come out calm, strong and well provisioned.
Mistakes to avoid
- Selecting after a single mild winter.
- Comparing colonies of different ages or sizes.
- Ignoring mites in fall.
- Using colonies with queen replacement as winter survivors without noting it.
- Overlooking drone diversity in the yard.
- Assuming that imported queens winter as the supplier's region does.
FAQ
How many winters should I test before choosing a breeder?
At least two, and ideally three or more, because winters vary. A line that survives one mild winter has not proven itself.
Do small colonies winter better or worse?
Strength matters. Very small colonies often fail from cold or low stores, but excessively large colonies can consume stores quickly. Aim for a mid-sized, healthy colony going into winter.
Can I improve winter survival just by choosing different bees?
Genetics help, but mites, nutrition, queen age and site matter as much. Combine selection with good management.