Choosing which colonies will become the mothers and fathers of the next generation is the central skill of the queen breeder, and most of it happens in the field with a hive tool, a notebook and patience. Selection that is fair, repeated and recorded improves a stock; selection based on impressions, a single bad or good day or a favorite queen simply preserves luck. This article explains how to set breeding goals, evaluate colonies in the field, build a selection index, decide how many breeders to keep and avoid the biases that spoil results. It links to the testing and testing-design articles for detail.
Start with goals
Write down the traits you want and rank them. Typical lists include gentleness, honey production, spring buildup, low swarming, winter survival, mite tolerance, hygienic behavior and brood pattern. Then decide what you will not compromise: for many breeders, gentleness and health are minimums rather than trade-offs.
A narrow list makes progress faster, but too narrow a list can sacrifice other traits. Choose three to six traits for scoring and keep notes on others. Your goals depend on your market: queen sellers need stock that sells and performs; honey producers need yield and winter survival; hobbyists need gentleness and ease.
Building the candidate pool
Select breeders from a large pool. If you test twenty colonies and take the best, you have more choice than if you test five. Pool sources can include your own colonies, purchased queens and survivor stock; see Local and Feral Bees: Survivor Stock. Keep all candidates under the same conditions for the test, as in Performance Testing: Colony Assessments.
Start with colonies that are queenright, disease-free and at least a season old, so that they have demonstrated survival. Avoid choosing from colonies that were fed or boosted more than the rest. Record how each colony was managed.
Field evaluation: what to look at
Evaluate each candidate on a schedule, not at random.
- Spring. Winter survival, buildup, brood pattern and stores.
- Flow. Population, swarming behavior, honey storage and gentleness.
- Summer and fall. Mite counts, disease, defensive behavior in dearth and preparation for winter.
- Winter. Weight, stores consumption and spring condition.
At each visit use a standard form; see Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs. Score traits on the same scale every time. Brood pattern is easiest to judge when the queen is laying well; see Recognizing a Healthy Brood Pattern. For mites, use a standardized count; see Varroa Monitoring: Alcohol Wash vs. Sugar Roll. For temperament, follow the approach in Breeding for Gentleness.
Building a selection index
Combine traits into one score. A simple method:
- List traits and give each a weight reflecting its importance. For example gentleness 25, honey 25, mite tolerance 20, winter survival 20, brood pattern 10.
- Score each colony on each trait from 1 to 5 using fixed definitions.
- Multiply scores by weights and sum.
- Rank colonies by total score.
- Set minimum thresholds on critical traits, so no colony with a very low gentleness or heavy disease is chosen regardless of total.
The index makes your priorities explicit and reduces the temptation to pick favorites. Adjust weights as your needs change but avoid changing them mid-season to favor a pet colony.
How many breeders to keep
Use enough breeders to maintain diversity but few enough to make progress. A typical guideline is to select roughly the top tenth to quarter of tested colonies as breeders, then spread daughters among them. Do not rely on a single breeder queen, since a failure would end the line and a narrow base risks inbreeding; see Inbreeding Depression in Bees. For a small program, aim for several breeders from different families. Rotate breeders annually and test daughters before reusing a breeder; see Progeny Testing Queens.
Controlling the drone side
Selection of queens is half the job. Drones determine the other half of each daughter's genes. Use drone colonies chosen by the same criteria, and place them where your queens will mate; see Drone Flooding: Saturation Technique, Apiary Isolation: Preventing Cross-Mating and Selecting Breeder Queens. Where isolation is impossible, accept slower progress or use insemination; see Instrumental Insemination: Technique and Use.
Avoiding bias and mistakes
Several biases spoil selection.
- Recency bias. Remember all seasons, not just the last.
- Confirmation bias. Score every colony blind to its pedigree if possible.
- Favorite queen bias. A queen you like is not necessarily the best; use numbers.
- Management bias. A colony that got extra frames looks better; equalize.
- Survivor bias. Survival alone is not enough; look at productivity and condition.
- Small sample bias. One colony does not make a line.
Randomize the order of colony visits, rotate scorers if more than one person is involved and calibrate scoring with a colleague.
A worked scoring example
Imagine three colonies at season's end. Colony 12 scores 5 for honey, 2 for gentleness, 4 for mites and 4 for winter survival. Colony 7 scores 4, 5, 4 and 4. Colony 3 scores 5, 4, 2 and 3. With weights of 25, 25, 20 and 20 (and brood pattern omitted for simplicity), colony 12 totals 5x25 plus 2x25 plus 4x20 plus 4x20, or 335. Colony 7 totals 4x25 plus 5x25 plus 4x20 plus 4x20, or 385. Colony 3 totals 5x25 plus 4x25 plus 2x20 plus 3x20, or 325. Colony 7 wins even though colony 12 made more honey, because it is gentle and balanced. If you had set a minimum gentleness threshold of 3, colony 12 would have been excluded at the first step. This is exactly what an index is for: it makes the trade-offs visible and keeps a single flashy trait from deciding the outcome.
Culling and requeening
Selection includes removing the poorest colonies as sources of drones and queens. Requeen or merge the lowest-scoring colonies, and prevent them from producing drones in the breeding yard by removing drone comb or replacing the queen. Do not breed from colonies with brood disease, chronic spotty pattern or extreme defensiveness. A strong cull keeps the pool improving. Record culled queens and the reason.
Putting it into a yearly cycle
| Season | Activity |
|---|---|
| Late winter | Review last year's records, plan crosses |
| Spring | Score winter survival and buildup, mark candidate breeders |
| Early summer | Graft from breeders, make nucs, flood with selected drones |
| Midsummer | Score honey, temperament, mites |
| Fall | Final scoring, pick next year's breeders, requeen cull colonies |
Keep each cycle consistent so data from different years can be compared. See Queen Rearing: An Introduction for production steps.
FAQ
How many colonies should I test before choosing a breeder?
More is better. Even with a small apiary, test all your colonies under the same conditions and select the top performers, while recognizing that small samples limit confidence.
Should I select from the best colony in one year?
Be cautious. Look for consistency across years and yards, and test daughters before treating a colony as a proven breeder.
Can I select for several traits at once?
Yes, using an index that weights each trait and thresholds for critical ones. Progress on each trait is slower than if you selected for only one, but the overall result is more useful.