Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Queens & Breeding › Breeding for Honey Production

Queens & Breeding

Breeding for Honey Production

Honey production is the trait most beekeepers want first, and it is also the trait that is hardest to select cleanly. Yield depends on genetics, but also on weather, forage, colony size, management, disease and the location of the yard. A breeder who wants to improve honey yield needs good data, large enough samples and a measure that separates genes from environment. This article explains what contributes to honey yield, how to measure it fairly, how to select breeders without sacrificing health and gentleness, and the pitfalls that mislead new breeders.

What produces a honey crop

A big honey crop is the result of several components working together:

  • Spring buildup. Colonies that build up on time for the main flow have more foragers.
  • Population at the flow. A large force of foragers brings in more nectar.
  • Foraging efficiency. Some colonies work more hours or travel further.
  • Low swarming. Colonies that swarm lose workers and brood during the flow.
  • Brood-nest management. Colonies that keep the brood nest compact and fill supers rather than clogging the nest with honey do better.
  • Disease and mite load. Sick colonies cannot forage well.
  • Winter survival. Surviving colonies are ready for the spring.

Selecting for honey means selecting for the combination of these. A colony that produces large honey crops year after year is usually good at several of them.

Heritability and why measurement is hard

Honey yield has moderate heritability in many studies, but the environment has a large effect. A colony in a good yard with a flow produces more than the same colony in a poor yard. The variation between colonies in the same yard is partly caused by differences in queen age, colony size at the start of the flow and local hive position. Because the queen's daughters are fathered by multiple drones, each colony's yield reflects a mixture of genes.

The practical lesson: measure many colonies under the same conditions, and repeat across years. See Performance Testing: Colony Assessments and Evaluating Queen Performance for general approaches.

Designing a fair honey test

A test that you can trust has these features:

  1. Same conditions. Place test colonies in the same yard or in yards of similar forage.
  2. Same start. Equalize colonies in spring: same number of frames of bees and brood, similar stores.
  3. Same age. Use queens of the same age, or record age and adjust.
  4. Same management. Give all colonies the same space, supers and swarm control.
  5. Include controls. Include your standard stock or a reference line so you can compare changes across years.
  6. Weigh honey. Weigh supers before and after extraction or use hive scales; see Honey Flow Management: When to Super. Weigh each colony's honey separately.
  7. Replicate. Repeat for at least two seasons.

Do not compare a colony in a spring flow yard with a colony in a fall flow yard, or a package-started colony with an overwintered one.

Recording honey data

Use a consistent system, and record at least: colony ID, queen ID and age, yard, spring strength, supers added, honey weighed, swarming, disease and notes; see Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs and Pedigree Records for Bee Breeders. Honey weight alone is not enough. A colony that made big honey but required constant swarm control or suffered heavy mite loads is not an ideal breeder.

A colony's honey crop is a result, not a trait. Record the traits that produced it.

Balancing honey with other traits

A good breeding program uses an index. For example, rank colonies on honey yield, gentleness, mite tolerance, winter survival, brood pattern and swarming. Weight each according to your goals. A colony that tops the honey list but fails on gentleness or disease should not be a breeder; see Breeding for Gentleness, Breeding for Disease Resistance and Breeding for Overwintering Success.

Some traits conflict. High-production colonies tend to be large and can swarm more; selecting for low swarming may reduce peak population. Heavy propolis users may produce less honey but be healthier. Decide what you value and be honest about trade-offs.

Selecting breeders

When you identify top colonies:

  • Make sure the honey result is repeatable, not one lucky year.
  • Check the colony's mite load and health.
  • Raise daughters from the best colonies by Grafting: The Doolittle Method or splitting.
  • Test the daughters in several yards; see Progeny Testing Queens.
  • Retain the best and cull the rest.

A queen with great honey but poor daughters is not a valuable breeder. Progeny testing separates the queen's own luck from her genes.

Environment and management effects

Beekeepers sometimes breed for performance that was due to management. A colony given extra supers early, extra brood frames from other hives or extra feed will look better than its neighbors. Equalizing and recording management prevent this error. Remember that migratory colonies, colonies on pollination contracts and colonies in different crop zones differ widely. Compare like with like.

For comb honey and specialty honey systems, selection targets differ: bees that cap cleanly, draw white wax and resist swarming matter more than raw weight; see Comb Honey Production. For commercial operations producing extracted honey, population at the flow and low swarming matter most.

Using hive scales and simple measures

Hive scales give a daily weight curve that shows buildup, flow dates and losses without opening the hive. Even a handful of scale hives in a yard can show when nectar comes in and which colonies respond fastest. Pair the curve with a few simple spring measures: frames of bees at a set date, frames of brood and the date the first super was needed. Colonies that reach strength early and hold it through the flow with little swarming are usually the ones that deliver the crop, and the early measures let you spot them before the flow ends. Keep notes on the dates of every major event so you can later separate a genetic advantage from a lucky head start.

Queen age is a hidden variable. A one-year-old queen usually outperforms a three-year-old in the same yard, so compare queens of equal age or you will select for youth, not genes.

Avoiding common mistakes

  • Selecting from a single season.
  • Comparing colonies in different yards.
  • Ignoring disease and mites.
  • Using queens of different ages.
  • Overselecting a single trait.
  • Failing to record management.
  • Believing that purchased "high production" stock will repeat in your yard; test it.

FAQ

How many colonies do I need to test honey production?

More is better, since random variation is large. Many breeders use at least ten to twenty colonies per stock in similar yards, and repeat over multiple seasons. Smaller programs can still learn by pooling results over years.

Can I breed for honey and gentleness at the same time?

Yes, using a selection index that weights both traits. Be careful to keep records for both, and avoid selecting only on one.

Why did my best honey colony produce poor daughters?

Honey yield depends heavily on environment and on the drones the queen mated with, so her performance does not always pass to daughters. Progeny testing helps identify queens that reliably produce good daughters.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →