Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Queens & Breeding › Progeny Testing Queens

Queens & Breeding

Progeny Testing Queens

A queen's own performance tells you what she did; her daughters tell you what she can pass on. Progeny testing is the practice of raising daughters from a candidate breeder, placing them in test colonies alongside daughters of other queens and judging the mother by how they perform. It is slow and takes dozens of colonies, but it is the most reliable way to identify breeder queens whose genes actually improve the stock, and it protects you from selecting colonies whose success came from luck, location or a lucky mating. This article explains how to design and run a progeny test, how to interpret results and how smaller breeders can use simplified versions.

Why test daughters

A queen's colony performance mixes her genes with her mates' genes and the environment. Her daughters carry half of her genes but also a mix of unknown drone genes. A colony that produced a record crop may owe it to an exceptional flow at its site, a lucky mating or extra management. Her daughters, tested in standard conditions, reveal whether the performance is heritable. See Selecting Breeder Queens and Evaluating Queen Performance.

Progeny testing is especially valuable for traits that are hard to see in the mother, such as hygienic behavior under mite stress, or for traits that appear in workers, such as gentleness. It is also essential before selling daughters of a breeder widely.

Designing the test

A basic design:

  1. Choose candidates. Select several breeder queens that have scored well in performance tests; see Performance Testing: Colony Assessments.
  2. Raise daughters. From each candidate, raise a group of daughters by Grafting: The Doolittle Method at the same time and in the same cell builder, so rearing conditions are equal.
  3. Mate them alike. Place mating nucs in the same yard with the same drone sources; see Drone Flooding: Saturation Technique.
  4. Introduce into test colonies. Use equalized colonies, with queens introduced at the same time.
  5. Distribute across yards. Place several daughters of each candidate in each of two or three yards, randomized.
  6. Include a control. Add daughters of a reference queen or standard stock.
  7. Score under standard conditions. Measure the same traits on the same dates.

How many daughters per candidate? More is better; ten or more across yards gives a decent picture, while four or five provide a rough guide. Smaller programs can use fewer and repeat across years.

Controlling the mating

The biggest weakness of progeny tests in honey bees is the drone side. Daughters of one queen mated openly are fathered by different drones, so differences between daughter groups may arise from the drones. Reduce this by mating all groups in the same yard at the same time with plentiful drones from selected colonies. Where possible use isolation or instrumental insemination with common semen; see Apiary Isolation: Preventing Cross-Mating and Instrumental Insemination: Technique and Use. If you can use semen from the same drone pool for all candidates, differences are more clearly maternal.

What to measure

Use the same measures as performance tests: temperament, brood pattern, buildup, honey, mite load, hygienic behavior, winter survival and swarming. Record every colony and every event, including queen loss. See Keeping Records: Hive Inspection Logs and Pedigree Records for Bee Breeders. Measure at fixed dates, and include at least one winter if you want to evaluate winter performance; see Breeding for Overwintering Success.

Interpreting the results

Average each daughter group across colonies and yards. Compare each group with the control and with the other groups. Then ask:

  • Are the daughters consistently better than the control?
  • Is variation within the group small, meaning the queen reliably passes traits?
  • Are there signs of hidden weakness such as disease susceptibility?
  • Did any group suffer from queen losses or poor matings unrelated to genes?

A mother whose daughters average well and vary little is a strong breeder. A mother whose daughters vary widely may have mated with variable drones or carry mixed genes, and is less reliable. A mother whose daughters are poor should be dropped even if she herself looked good.

Using the results

  • Keep and use the best mothers as breeders, and retain more than one so you maintain diversity.
  • Graft from their colonies to produce production queens.
  • Keep records of the tested lines and use them in marketing honestly.
  • Drop or limit lines that perform poorly.
  • Repeat the test for promising queens over a second year.

Be aware of the time lag. By the time you finish a two-year test the mother may be old or dead. Preserve her line by keeping daughters or banking her while testing; see Queen Banking: Holding Extra Queens and Two-Queen Colonies: Advanced Management. Some breeders produce a few extra daughters from each candidate and keep them as reserve breeders until the results are known.

Simplified testing for small breeders

If you cannot run a full test:

  • Raise five or six daughters from each of two or three candidate queens and place them in your own colonies.
  • Compare them with colonies headed by your standard queens.
  • Cooperate with a neighboring beekeeper or club to place daughters in more yards; see Joining a Local Beekeeping Club: Why It's Essential.
  • Use a short list of measures.
  • Accept that conclusions are tentative.

Even a modest test gives better information than none, and results accumulate over years.

Reading the results year by year

Results from the first year are rarely the whole story. In year one you learn whether daughters were accepted, mated and built up, and you can score temperament and early buildup. In year two you see winter survival, spring strength and the first full honey flow of a mature queen. Only after two seasons can you judge persistence, since some queens do well while young and fail in their second year. Keep a running table of each mother's daughters, with a row per colony and a column per season, and note the loss of any daughter and why. A mother who has two good years of data from several daughters is far more valuable than one who has a single strong season.

Cost and effort

Progeny testing is expensive in time, equipment and colonies. Budget for extra mating nucs, queen cells, test colonies and record keeping. Cooperative programs and breeder groups can share costs. If you sell queens, test results are an asset and can justify your pricing; see Selling Queens: Regulations and Shipping.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Testing too few daughters.
  • Mating groups in different places.
  • Using colonies of different strength.
  • Ignoring the drone side.
  • Basing decisions on one season.
  • Losing the mother before results arrive.
  • Failing to record queen losses.

FAQ

How many daughters should I test per queen?

More is better. About ten across several yards gives a decent picture, while smaller groups give rough guidance. Repeat in later years where you can.

Is progeny testing worth it for a small apiary?

A simplified version is. Even a few daughters per candidate compared with a control can reveal useful differences, though conclusions will be tentative.

What if the mother dies before the test finishes?

Keep some daughters as reserve breeders, or bank the mother if possible, so the line is not lost while you wait for results.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →