A grafted larva is only as good as the colony that raises it. Cell builders are the colonies that accept, feed and cap queen cells, and the system you use to build them affects queen size, emergence weight and later performance as much as the larva itself. Beekeepers use starter colonies, finisher colonies, and queenright builders, often in combination. This article explains how each works, how to prepare them, how to choose a configuration that matches your scale, and how to troubleshoot colonies that refuse or poorly feed cells.
What a good cell builder does
Queens are made by nurse bees, roughly five to fifteen days old, whose hypopharyngeal glands produce royal jelly. A good builder concentrates those nurses, keeps them well fed, and puts them in an emotional state favorable to building: either queenless and wanting a queen, or queenright but crowded and in the mood to swarm. Both approaches work, and well-prepared colonies of either type can produce excellent queens.
The key requirements are the same everywhere. The colony needs a huge population of nurse bees compared with the amount of open brood, a continuous supply of nectar or syrup, and ample pollen or pollen substitute. When any of these is missing, cells shrink, jelly dries up and acceptance falls. See Queen Rearing: An Introduction for how this fits into a whole rearing cycle.
Queenless starter colonies
A starter is a queenless colony whose job is to receive freshly grafted cells and feed them heavily for the first 24 to 48 hours, when acceptance is decided and the larva needs the most attention. Because it has no queen and no open brood, every nurse bee turns attention to the new cells.
Typical preparation takes the following form:
- Choose a strong colony, often a double-deep or a large box of bees.
- Remove the queen along with a frame or two of brood, and place them in a split to keep her safe.
- Shake extra nurse bees from several frames into the starter, so it is jammed.
- Add frames of honey and pollen, and feed syrup.
- Wait about two hours, then give the grafted bar.
A smaller version of the same idea uses little boxes, covered in Queenless Starter Nucs. Starters are excellent for acceptance but are less ideal for long cell development, because queenless colonies eventually lose nurses to older tasks and may start laying workers.
Finisher colonies
A finisher takes cells from the starter after about 24 hours, once acceptance is certain, and carries them to capping and ripeness. Finishers are usually queenright, strong colonies, often with a queen excluder below the cell frame so the queen stays in the lower box. The bees in the upper box are crowded, fed and have access to larvae and a swarming impulse that sustain cell care.
Finishers must be stocked with nurse bees and kept busy. Because they are queenright, their brood pheromone suppresses laying workers and keeps the colony stable over many cycles. A well-run finisher can complete a few batches of cells before being rebuilt. A starter-finisher system gives the best of both: the intense early feeding of a queenless colony and the stable, long-lasting support of a queenright one.
Queenright builders
A queenright builder raises cells in a colony with its queen present, usually by keeping her below with an excluder and placing a cell frame in the box above. Brood above is limited, nurses crowd up through the excluder, and the colony tends to accept and finish cells without a starter stage.
This approach is simple, scales well, and avoids dealing with queenless colonies, so it suits beginners and hobbyists. It does rely on a strong nectar flow or steady feeding, and on keeping the box above jammed with nurse bees. Opening the bottom box and adding frames of emerging brood to the top box refreshes the nurse population every few days. For ideas about excluder use, see Queen Excluder Management for Breeders.
Comparing the systems
| System | Strength | Weakness | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Queenless starter | Highest early acceptance | Short lifespan, lays workers eventually | Commercial and serious hobbyists |
| Finisher (queenright) | Stable, repeatable | Needs a good flow | Anyone with a strong colony |
| Queenright builder only | Simplest | Slightly lower acceptance | Beginners, small scale |
| Cloake board | Stable queenless phase | Requires board and timing | Moderate scale, see Cloake Board Method |
The right choice depends on how many queens you want per cycle, how many colonies you can spare, and your season. Many queen breeders run a small number of dedicated builders year after year, because stable colonies that are rebuilt on a schedule are easier to manage than ones recreated each time.
Feeding and nurse bee management
Nurse bees are the raw material. A builder colony should hold bees from nearly every frame of brood in its yard, and the surplus is often shaken in from donor colonies. Pull frames of capped brood, which will emerge into young bees over the next days, to keep the nurse population climbing.
Feed generously. A typical program uses light syrup, around 1:1 sugar to water, when no nectar is coming in, plus pollen or patty if pollen is scarce. Continuous feeding, rather than a large dose that backs the brood nest with syrup, gives the best results. Do not feed honey from unknown sources, which could carry disease. Good feeding practices are discussed in Feeding Bees: 4-H Project Responsibilities.
Keep the builder warm and ventilated, protected from cold nights, and shaded against midday heat. A builder that is cold at night or heat-stressed in the afternoon will produce thin cells.
Managing the cell bar
Once the bar is in, handling matters. Place it in the center of the box, between frames of open brood. Check after 24 hours to see which cups were accepted. Remove failed cups, and consider moving the bar to a finisher if you run a two-stage system. At day five or six, cells are capped. From about day nine or ten, they should be protected, either in a cell protector, a bank colony as in Cell Banking and Transport, or in mating nucs with a ripe cell inserted.
Watch for the bees building emergency cells on the brood combs when a builder is queenless. Cut these out on every visit, since otherwise the bees may favor them and neglect your grafts. A routine check every three to four days is usually enough.
Common problems and fixes
- Cells poorly fed, small or dry. The builder lacks nurses or feed. Add brood and syrup, and shake in nurses.
- Bees tear down accepted cells. Often a sign of a weak flow, a disturbed colony or a wandering queen. Check queen status.
- Laying workers appear. A starter queenless too long. Introduce a frame of open brood or end the cycle.
- Mites and disease. Cell builders should be among your healthiest colonies. Monitor for mites and treat according to label, as discussed in Integrated Pest Management for Varroa.
- Builder swarms. A crowded queenright builder may swarm. Provide room above and manage the swarm impulse as in Swarm Season: Prevention and Management.
Keep notes on each builder: how many nurses, what you fed, how many cells were accepted and how large they were at capping. The data help you see which setup is best for your location.
Rebuilding between cycles
Between cycles, give builders a rest. A queenless starter should be given a young queen or a ripe cell after its work is done. A finisher should have its brood balanced, and its excess honey or pollen tidied. Rotating builders helps keep them strong. With care, the same colonies can serve many seasons, and those years of notes become your most valuable asset.
FAQ
Do I need both a starter and a finisher?
No. A single strong queenright builder with an excluder can work well, and a starter-finisher pairing mainly improves early acceptance and cell quality, which matters more at larger scale.
How long should cells stay in a starter?
Typically about 24 hours, long enough to confirm acceptance and give the first intense feeding, after which cells are moved to a finisher or a stable queenright colony.
What makes a colony a good builder?
Lots of young nurse bees, steady incoming nectar or syrup, plenty of pollen, and a calm, crowded state, with no competing emergency cells being built.