Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Queens & Breeding › Performance Testing: Colony Assessments

Queens & Breeding

Performance Testing: Colony Assessments

Performance testing is how a breeder turns opinions about bees into evidence. By running colonies side by side under the same conditions and recording what they do, you can tell which queens, lines or crosses genuinely perform better and which were simply lucky or well looked after. Done poorly, tests mislead and encourage wrong decisions; done well, they are the foundation of every selection program. This article covers designing a fair test, choosing what to measure, standard protocols, statistics a beekeeper can use without a degree, how to run tests in small apiaries and the common traps.

Principles of a fair test

A good test has four features.

  • Comparability. Colonies are as alike as possible at the start: same size, same age of queen, same stores, same equipment.
  • Replication. Several colonies per queen or line, so one unlucky colony does not decide the result.
  • Randomization. Colonies of each line are assigned to positions and yards at random, so yard effects do not favor one line.
  • Repetition. Tests run across multiple seasons and ideally multiple sites.

Without these, differences cannot be attributed to genetics. See Evaluating Queen Performance for the evaluation of an individual queen and Breeding Stock Selection: Field Evaluation for how test results feed decisions.

What to measure

Choose measures that are objective, repeatable and relevant.

TraitMeasure
GentlenessStandard score on 1 to 4 scale, repeated
Spring buildupFrames of bees or brood at a fixed date
Honey productionWeight of honey per colony
SwarmingNumber of colonies making swarm cells
Mite loadMites per hundred bees at set dates
Hygienic behaviorFreeze or pin test removal rate
Winter survivalAlive and strong in spring
Brood patternPercent solid brood on a standard frame area

See Varroa Monitoring: Alcohol Wash vs. Sugar Roll, Hygienic Behavior: The Genetic Basis and Honey Flow Management: When to Super for how to take specific measures. Choose a small number and measure them well rather than many poorly.

Setting up the test

  1. Raise queens together. Test queens should be the same age and raised in the same batch conditions where possible.
  2. Prepare colonies. Use colonies of equal strength; equalize frames of bees, brood and food, and make sure there is no disease.
  3. Introduce the queens. Introduce test queens into colonies that are queenless in the same way and at the same time; see Queen Introduction: Direct vs. Cage Methods.
  4. Place colonies. Use a layout that spreads each line across the yard, with a mix of positions and orientations.
  5. Standardize management. Same supers, same swarm control, same treatment, same feeding.
  6. Mark and record. Label every colony and queen; see Marking and Tracking Queens.
  7. Schedule visits. Plan which tasks you do on which dates and stick to the plan.

Think about the effect of drift: in a straight row, bees drift toward end hives. Place colonies in a pattern that varies direction or in small groups, and record positions.

Test colonies in more than one yard

A single yard tests how a line behaves in that yard. A trait that appears in one yard may vanish in another. Place the same set of lines in two or three yards that differ in forage or climate. A line that performs well across yards is more robust. If you cannot manage multiple yards, repeat the test over years.

Simple statistics

You do not need advanced mathematics, but a few ideas help.

  • Average and spread. Compute the average for each line and look at the range; if ranges overlap heavily the difference may be chance.
  • Replication. With only two colonies per line, a difference can arise by chance. Use more.
  • Rank rather than raw numbers. If measurements are noisy, ranking within yard can help.
  • Look for consistency. A line that is in the top half in most colonies and years is more reliable than one with a single exceptional colony.

If you are working in a program with a university or extension partner, ask for help with analysis. See Honey Bee Genetics: Haplodiploidy Explained for the genetics behind it.

Testing in a small apiary

If you have few colonies, you can still test.

  • Combine data across years and treat each year as a replicate.
  • Compare each colony to a standard reference queen kept in the apiary.
  • Share data and test colonies with neighboring beekeepers or a club; see Joining a Local Beekeeping Club: Why It's Essential.
  • Keep your list of traits short.

Be honest about the limits. With five colonies you can detect only very large differences. Use results as guidance, not proof.

Testing for specific traits

Some traits need special tests. For hygienic behavior, use standardized freeze or pin tests and repeat them. For mite resistance, monitor mite growth over several months with no treatment only if you can rescue colonies; otherwise use a threshold approach with treatment; see Integrated Pest Management for Varroa. For winter performance, equalize in fall and record spring strength; see Breeding for Overwintering Success. For temperament, use consistent scoring; see Breeding for Gentleness.

Interpreting results

After testing, ask:

  • Is the difference large enough to matter in practice?
  • Is it consistent across colonies, yards and years?
  • Did anything unusual happen, such as queen loss, disease or robbing?
  • Does the better line show weaknesses in other traits?
  • Can I repeat the result with daughters of the best queens?

A single test seldom justifies a major change. Combine results with progeny tests; see Progeny Testing Queens.

A sample season plan

Spring: equalize test colonies in the first warm weeks, introduce test queens and record the starting frames of bees. Early summer: score gentleness on three separate days, record swarm cells and supers added. Midsummer: weigh honey, take the first mite wash. Late summer: take a second mite wash, score brood pattern and note any disease. Fall: equalize feed, record weights and take a final mite count after treatment. Late winter and early spring: record survival, spring strength and stores. Between rounds, enter the data the same evening. Keep a one-page summary for each colony so that when winter ends you can pull the whole record in minutes and rank colonies without relying on memory.

Write the test plan down before you start, including what you will measure, when and how you will decide the winner. Plans written after the results are in tend to favor the colonies you already liked.

Common traps

  • Using colonies of different strength.
  • Mixing queen ages.
  • Forgetting to randomize.
  • Testing only once.
  • Changing measures partway through.
  • Ignoring failed or lost colonies; record every colony, including those that were lost.
  • Treating differences within measurement error as real.

FAQ

How many colonies per line do I need?

As many as you can manage, with several being the practical minimum. More colonies reduce the effect of chance, and you can add replication by repeating over years.

Do I need a control line?

Yes, ideally. A control of your standard stock lets you compare results across years and conditions.

How long should a performance test last?

At least one full season, ideally through winter and a second year, because many traits show only over time.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →