Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Queens & Breeding › Cloake Board Method

Queens & Breeding

Cloake Board Method

The Cloake board method, named for beekeeper Brian Cloake, is a way to raise grafted queen cells in a strong queenright colony that is split into queenless and queenright halves by a special board. A single colony supplies both the heavy nursing of a queenless starter and the stability of a queenright finisher, without moving cells or bees between boxes. Many hobbyists and small-scale queen producers like it because it keeps the cell-building colony healthy and contained in one stack. This article explains how the board works, the timing of a cycle, how to set it up, and what to watch for.

How the board works

A Cloake board is a flat board, usually the size of a hive body, with a queen excluder cutout in the center and a slide or shutter that can close the opening. It sits between two boxes. When the slide is open, bees and pheromones pass freely between the lower queenright box and the upper box. When the slide is closed, the upper box is sealed off from the queen below, and the bees there become queenless within hours. The upper box typically has its own entrance at the back, so foragers can return.

That design creates a queenless starter on top of a queenright colony, with the queen in the box below keeping the lower bees stable. When you reopen the slide after grafts are accepted, the upper box returns to queenright and finishes the cells with the stability of a normal colony. For comparison with traditional starters, see Queen Cell Builders and Starter/Finisher Colonies.

Preparing the colony

Choose a strong colony with a prolific queen, ideally two boxes or more, in a good flow. A few days before grafting, you will arrange the stack so the upper box is rich in nurse bees and feed.

Preparation steps are:

  1. Place the queen in the lower box, with open brood and some capped brood, below a queen excluder or the closed board.
  2. Move frames of emerging and sealed brood to the upper box, along with frames of honey and pollen.
  3. Add a frame of unsealed brood in the upper box, which keeps nurses attracted to it.
  4. Shake additional nurse bees into the upper box from donor colonies if the population is thin.
  5. Put the board on with the slide closed, leaving the upper box queenless.

Feed the upper box generously if the flow is weak. Nurses in a crowded queenless box will raise cells beautifully when fed. As with all building methods, consider the season: a Cloake board in the middle of a dearth is a recipe for poor cells, as discussed in Queen Rearing: An Introduction.

A typical timeline

Cloake board timing is usually organized around the day the board is closed.

DayAction
0Close the slide, making the upper box queenless
1Graft larvae and insert the bar into the upper box, in the center
2Check acceptance, remove failed cups
3Open the slide, returning the upper box to queenright
8 to 10Cells capped and nearly ripe
10 to 11Move cells to mating nucs or a bank

Many writers describe a slightly different sequence, with the board closed for about 24 hours before grafting. What matters is that the upper box has been queenless long enough that the bees feel the need for a queen and are ready to accept grafted cups, while the grafting is done when larvae are the right age. Adjust the exact hours to your own colony and note what works.

Doing the graft

While the box stays queenless, graft larvae from your selected breeder as in Grafting: The Doolittle Method, and place the bar in the center of the upper box, between frames of open brood. Check about 24 hours later to confirm which cups were accepted. Then open the slide.

Opening the slide lets the queen's pheromone flow upward again, which calms the bees and stops them from building emergency cells on brood combs, while the nurses continue feeding the accepted cells. This is the benefit of the Cloake board: the high early acceptance of a queenless starter followed by the stability of a queenright finisher, all in the same colony.

Advantages and disadvantages

The method has real advantages.

  • A single colony serves as starter and finisher, saving equipment and effort.
  • The colony stays whole and healthy, with a queen laying continuously below.
  • Cells need not be moved between colonies during early stages, reducing handling.
  • The setup scales to a small number of cells at a time, which suits hobbyists.

It also has drawbacks.

  • You need a purpose-built board and a hive stack that fits it.
  • Timing is more fixed than in simpler methods, with less margin for error.
  • The upper box needs to be crowded, which means pulling brood from other colonies.
  • Success depends on a good flow or reliable feeding.

For beekeepers who want to raise queens occasionally without maintaining separate starter and finisher colonies, the board is a good fit. For those who raise queens repeatedly in large numbers, a dedicated starter-finisher system may produce more consistent results.

Troubleshooting

Problems tend to cluster around a few causes.

  • Poor acceptance. The upper box was not truly queenless, or lacked nurses. Check that the slide is sealed and that the box has no leaks. Add more nurse bees.
  • Bees building emergency cells on combs. Cut them out every visit. They compete with your grafts for nurse attention.
  • Queen moves up. If the queen reaches the upper box before closing, remove her and place her below. Check carefully for eggs and the queen before closing the board.
  • Cells poorly fed or small. Add feed and nurse bees. In a dearth, provide syrup and pollen substitute.
  • Robbing. An unattended entrance on the upper box can invite robbers. Reduce entrances during a dearth, a practice also discussed in Apiary Hygiene: Equipment Cleaning and Disinfection.

Keep notes on weather, flow, population and acceptance. You will see patterns, and those patterns are how the board becomes predictable.

After the cycle

When cells are ripe, remove the bar. Cells can go into mating nucs with a ripe cell, as covered in Mating Nucs: Setup and Management, or into a cell bank, as in Cell Banking and Transport. Return the upper box to its normal state by removing the board, restoring the queenright colony, and giving the bees a chance to rebuild. A Cloake colony can be used repeatedly through the season, as long as it is kept strong, fed and free of disease.

Assess your results. How many cups were accepted? How large were the cells at capping? How many queens emerged, mated and began laying? Those numbers tell you whether the board is worth the effort in your yard. Track the colonies the queens end up in, because performance over a full season is the only proof of a good queen, as explained in Evaluating Queen Performance.

FAQ

Do I need a special board for the Cloake method?

Yes, a Cloake board with an excluder cutout and a closable slide is what creates the queenless upper box, though some beekeepers build their own from wood and excluder material.

Can I use the Cloake board for a single batch of cells?

Yes, it works well for one batch at a time, and the same colony can be reused for repeated cycles as long as it remains strong and well fed.

How long should the upper box stay queenless?

About a day before grafting and until the grafts are accepted, usually a total of two to three days, after which opening the slide returns the box to a queenright state.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →