Drone brood removal is a cultural control that uses the varroa mite's preference for drone cells to trap and remove a share of the mite population without chemicals. You give the colony a frame or section of drone comb, let the queen lay in it, and remove the capped drone brood before the drones emerge. Because mites invade drone cells at a much higher rate than worker cells, a large share of the mites go out with the brood. This article explains the method, timing, tools, limits, and how to fit it into a broader plan.
Why It Works
Mites prefer drone brood. The capped period for a drone is about 14 days compared with about 12 for a worker, so a foundress mite can raise more mature daughters in a drone cell. Chemical cues also draw mites toward drone larvae. As a result, drone cells are infested at several times the rate of worker cells. See Varroa Lifecycle: Understanding the Enemy for how mites reproduce in brood.
If you remove drone brood just before the drones emerge, you remove the mites with it, and you also stop the mites inside from reproducing and moving to adult bees. Repeating the cycle through the spring and early summer can remove a meaningful part of the population when counts are still low.
Drones are about 24 days from egg to emergence; see Drone Bees: Purpose and Management and Brood Development Stages by Day. Capped drone brood is ready for removal about 21 days after the queen laid the eggs, or a few days before emergence.
What You Need
You do not need specialized equipment, though a few items make the job easier.
- A drone frame. A frame with larger cell foundation or a frame with a drone-sized foundation. A shallow frame or a half-frame in a deep box, where bees will build drone comb in the empty space, also works.
- Foundationless frames. Some beekeepers use an empty frame, or a frame with a starter strip, and allow bees to build drone comb naturally. See Foundationless Frames: Pros and Cons.
- A hive tool and a method of removal. You can cut the comb out, uncap and wash, or freeze the frame.
- A freezer, if you plan to reuse the comb. Freezing kills the brood and the mites, and the bees clean it out and reuse it.
If you use a frame with drone foundation, make sure it is clearly marked so you remember to remove it on time.
Step-by-Step Method
- In spring, once drone comb is being built and the colony has drones, place a drone frame in the brood nest, usually next to the brood or at the edge, as the bees accept it.
- Wait for the queen to lay and the cells to be capped. Capped drone brood has a domed, bullet-shaped cap that stands out from flat worker cappings.
- Inspect after about 21 to 24 days from the first eggs. The brood should be mostly capped. Remove the frame before the drones emerge.
- Remove the brood. Options: cut out the comb and discard it, freeze the whole frame for at least 24 hours and return it to the hive for the bees to clean, or uncap the cells and wash out the contents.
- Return the empty frame, or a fresh one, to the colony. Repeat the cycle every 3 weeks or so while the colony continues to produce drones.
Do not leave the frame beyond emergence. If you wait too long, the drones emerge and the mites move to adult bees, undoing the benefit. If you leave the cells too long the bees may also build burr comb.
Timing and Season
The best time to use drone brood removal is in spring and early summer, when the colony is raising drones and mite numbers are rising but still low. A colony that starts the season with a low mite count and removes three or four drone frames in sequence may stay under threshold longer.
Late in the season, colonies often stop producing drone brood, and the method loses effect. It is not suitable for a late-summer rescue when counts are high. At that stage, a treatment is needed. See Integrated Pest Management for Varroa.
In regions where beekeepers keep drones through the whole season, the method can be used longer, but the response depends on the stock. Check local knowledge from your state beekeeping association or extension office.
How Much Will It Help?
Drone brood removal is a modest tool. The proportion of mites removed varies with the amount of drone brood and the timing. Studies and beekeeper experience suggest it can lower mite growth but rarely controls a heavy infestation alone. It is best seen as a way to slow the growth of mites during the spring and early summer.
Colonies that do not build much drone comb, or that have fewer drones due to season or stock, remove fewer mites. A colony that already has a very high count may not be saved by drone removal.
Do not use it as the only control if your counts are close to threshold. Use monitoring, as in Varroa Monitoring: Alcohol Wash vs. Sugar Roll, to decide whether additional action is required. A successful program keeps a record of counts so you can see the effect.
Effects on the Colony
Drones matter. They are needed for mating, and a colony with no drones at all in spring may suffer in queen supersedure or swarm preparation. Removing one frame at a time leaves plenty of drones in the colony and the area. Do not strip all drone comb from the hive.
Bees will try to rebuild drone comb in empty space. If you leave gaps in frames, expect drone comb to appear in unexpected places. This is a minor annoyance, and also a mite trap: the colony is building the trap for you.
There is some energy cost. A colony spends resources raising drone brood that you then remove, and it may slightly affect honey production in a colony that is already stressed. Most healthy colonies tolerate it well.
If you are raising queens, consider your need for drones. Breeders who rely on drone sources will want to maintain drones in selected colonies and use drone removal in others. See Drone Flooding: Saturation Technique and Mating Flights and Drone Congregation Areas.
Combining with Other Methods
Drone brood removal works best with other tools:
- Monitoring to track the effect. See Varroa EasyCheck and Monitoring Tools
- Brood breaks via Queen Trapping: Breaking the Brood Cycle, which also concentrates mites on adult bees
- Splits that create a brood-free period in the new queen's colony
- Resistant stock, such as VSH (Varroa Sensitive Hygiene) Stock
- A treatment when counts exceed threshold, such as Oxalic Acid Vaporization: Protocol and Safety in a broodless window
Remember that drone brood trapping is not a replacement for treatment. It reduces the pressure on the colony so that treatments are more effective, less frequent and timed better.
Common Mistakes
- Waiting too long and letting drones emerge
- Not marking the frame
- Removing all drone comb
- Using it as the only control against a high count
- Starting too late in the season
- Not checking whether the cells were capped
- Letting the freezer frame thaw too soon or not freezing long enough, so some brood survives
- Leaving the frame in too long, so drones emerge and mites spread
- Failing to record dates, so the 3-week cycle slips
- Confusing drone brood with laying-worker brood; see Laying Workers: When the Queen Is Gone
If you are unsure whether you have drone brood, compare the capping: drone cappings are raised and rounded, while worker cappings are flatter. An experienced beekeeper can show you in person.
FAQ
How often should I remove drone brood?
Roughly every three weeks, before the capped drones emerge, as long as the colony keeps raising drones in the season.
Can I put the frame back after freezing?
Yes, freezing for at least 24 hours kills the brood and mites, and the bees will clean out and reuse the comb.
Is drone brood removal enough to control varroa?
Rarely, since it slows mite growth but usually cannot control a high count, so keep monitoring and treat when counts reach the threshold.