Most queen introduction advice assumes the old queen is already gone. Sometimes she is not. You may want to replace a failing queen without ever making the colony queenless, run a two-queen unit, or swap a mean queen for a gentle one while keeping brood production going. Introducing a queen to a colony that still has a queen, or that has just had one removed, requires a gentler approach, because workers defend the queen they have. This article explains why queenright introduction works at all, the main methods, the preparation that raises success, and what to do when a new queen is rejected.
Why queenright introduction is harder
A queenright colony is saturated with its own queen's pheromones, and its workers actively reject outsiders. Drop a new queen into the box and the likely outcome is balling, where workers cluster and kill her. For that reason, the standard advice is to remove the old queen first, wait a day, then introduce the replacement, as in Queen Introduction: Direct vs. Cage Methods.
Sometimes that is not practical. A beekeeper who cannot find the old queen, who wants to keep brood going during a flow, or who is requeening a very large colony may prefer to unite instead. The idea is to let the colony gradually get used to the new queen's scent while the old queen is still present or only just removed. That slow merging gives workers time to adjust, and it works best with a young, vigorous, well-accepted queen.
The newspaper method
The classic approach combines the new queen's colony with the old one, separated by newspaper. Bees chew through the paper over a day or two, and by then the scents have mixed.
- Make up a small nucleus or box with the new queen, with her own bees and brood, or hold her in a cage in a nuc.
- Remove the old queen from the main colony if you can find her, since it greatly improves the odds.
- Place a sheet of newspaper over the top of the main colony's upper box, with a few small slits cut in it.
- Set the new queen's box on top, with the queen and her bees.
- Close the hive. In a day or two the bees chew through, and the colonies merge.
- After about a week, check the colony and remove the extra box and paper.
If the old queen was not removed, the colony may settle the matter itself, usually in favor of the younger or stronger queen, but sometimes both are killed. For more on keeping two queens in a colony deliberately, see Two-Queen Colonies: Advanced Management and Double-Queen Systems: Advanced Management.
Cage and queen excluder methods
Another approach uses a cage and a barrier. A queen in a cage can sit within the colony, between brood frames, while the old queen continues laying. The cage allows workers to feed and touch the new queen through the screen without reaching her directly.
A more elaborate alternative uses a queen excluder to separate the new queen above from the old queen below. Bees pass freely between the levels but the queens cannot meet, and the colony absorbs both scents. After a few days, you remove the old queen and the colony accepts the new one through the excluder. This is a good approach for beekeepers running double-queen systems and for requeening strong colonies in a flow.
Making a colony ready
Preparation increases success. Whichever method you choose, apply the same foundations.
- Strong flow or heavy feeding. Bees with plenty of food are calmer and more accepting.
- Young queen. Young queens usually carry attractive pheromone and are more readily accepted.
- Calm handling. Work in the middle of the day, with minimal smoke and no rough bumping.
- Healthy colony. Treat for mites and rule out disease first, as in Integrated Pest Management for Varroa.
- No emergency cells. Destroy cells or the colony may keep its own preferred queen.
- Reduced entrance. A small entrance reduces robbing and drifting during the process.
If the old queen is aggressive, defensive or poorly mated and you plan to remove her, find her first. See Finding the Queen: Tips for Beginners for techniques. Marked queens make this easier, as described in Marking and Tracking Queens.
Ripe cells and virgins as an alternative
When replacing a queen in a queenright colony, a ripe queen cell sometimes works better than a mated queen. A cell, placed in a protector in the brood nest, does not have the smell of an outsider. The virgin emerges inside the colony, and the colony may accept her as a replacement, particularly if the old queen was removed a day or more before. However, virgins must still mate, and weather and drones matter, as explained in Queen Mating Biology: Timing and Success.
A less risky variation is to make a split with the new queen, let her establish and start laying, and then combine the split with the old colony via newspaper after removing the old queen. This extra step costs a few weeks but gives you proven laying and a known quality, and it is the preferred method for expensive or valuable queens.
What if she is rejected
Signs of rejection include workers clustering and gripping a caged queen, a dead queen found on the bottom board or at the entrance, new queen cells, or a sudden disappearance of the new queen. If you see balling, act quickly. Smoke the cluster and, if the queen is still alive, gently separate them and place her in a cage in a nuc to recover.
After rejection, check the colony. Is the old queen still present? Does the colony have laying workers? Has it begun to build emergency cells? Use the findings to decide what to do next. In many cases, the best fix is to remove the old queen, wait a day, remove any cells, and try again with a cage and fresh queen. See Queen Acceptance: Factors and Failures for deeper analysis of why acceptance fails.
A decision guide
| Situation | Suggested approach |
|---|---|
| Old queen found and removed | Wait a day, introduce in a cage |
| Old queen cannot be found | Newspaper combine with a nuc |
| Strong flow, valuable queen | Make a split with her first, then combine |
| Running two queens deliberately | Excluder separation between levels |
| Failing queen, colony in good shape | Ripe cell after removing the old queen |
Choose the least risky approach that fits your skill and your supplies. Keep notes on what worked, because every apiary has quirks, and records improve results.
FAQ
Can I add a new queen without removing the old one?
Only with a gradual method, such as a newspaper combine or a barrier like an excluder, because a direct introduction to a queenright colony usually ends with workers killing the new queen.
How long do I wait after removing the old queen?
About 24 hours is a common interval, which lets the colony notice the loss without letting laying workers or emergency cells develop.
What is the safest way to requeen with a valuable queen?
Make a small split with the new queen, let her start laying, then unite the split with the old colony using newspaper after removing the old queen.