Beekeeping Directory

Home › Guides › Bee Biology & Colony Life › After-Swarms and Cast Swarms

Bee Biology & Colony Life

After-Swarms and Cast Swarms

After a colony sends out its prime swarm, it may release one or more additional swarms led by virgin queens. These are called after-swarms, and the smaller, later ones are often called cast swarms or casts. They are a normal part of swarm biology, but they are costly to the parent colony, hard to predict and frequently disappointing for beekeepers who catch them. This article explains how after-swarms arise, how to tell them from prime swarms, what is happening with the queens, and how to handle them in the apiary, from prevention to recovery.

How After-Swarms Arise

When a colony prepares to swarm, it raises several queen cells, typically staggered by a few days. The old queen leaves with the prime swarm before the first of those queens emerges, usually around the time the first cells are capped. That leaves the parent colony with a set of developing queens at various stages.

The first virgin to emerge may do one of two things. She may seek out the other queen cells and destroy them by chewing through the side and stinging the occupants, or workers may guard the remaining cells and keep her away from them. Which happens depends on colony conditions, genetics and the size of the remaining worker population. When workers protect the cells, the colony retains the option of sending out further swarms.

The virgin that emerges first often "pipes," making a quacking or tooting sound. Other queens still inside their cells answer with a quieter "quacking" call. Beekeepers who hear piping near the hive in late spring know that after-swarming may be underway. The sound can be heard at the entrance or by pressing an ear to the hive wall.

Prime Swarm vs. After-Swarm vs. Cast

Three terms appear in the literature, and usage varies slightly. The sequence generally goes like this.

TypeQueenTypical timingSize
Prime swarmOld, mated queenAround first cell cappingLargest, often half or more of the workers
Second swarm (after-swarm)Virgin queenAbout a week after the prime swarmSmaller
Third and later swarms (casts)Virgin queen(s)Days after the secondVery small, sometimes only a handful of bees per queen

Terminology is not rigid, and many beekeepers use "cast" for any after-swarm. The practical differences matter more. A prime swarm contains a mated, laying queen and can start building comb immediately. An after-swarm contains a virgin who must fly out, mate and return before the new colony can produce brood. A cast with a handful of bees is unlikely to survive on its own.

Casts can also contain several virgin queens at once, which is unusual among animals and unlike the usual single-queen state. The multiple queens eventually fight, and only one is left.

Why They Are Riskier for the New Colony

A swarm headed by a virgin queen faces a hazard that a prime swarm does not: the queen must mate. She will make mating flights over the days after settling, and each flight exposes her to predators, bad weather and failure to find drones. A queen that fails to mate within a few weeks may become a drone layer, laying only unfertilized eggs. See queen mating biology.

Colony size compounds the problem. After-swarms often have too few workers to build comb, forage and defend a nest while the queen mates. In temperate regions, a late cast may not accumulate enough stores to survive winter, especially if swarming happens late in the season.

Mating success also depends on the density of drones nearby. Late in the season, drones may be scarce or be expelled in a dearth, so virgin queens from late casts can have trouble mating well. See mating flights and drone congregation areas.

Effects on the Parent Colony

Each after-swarm takes more workers from the parent colony, so repeated swarming can drain the parent to a handful of bees with a queen that has yet to mate. This is the main reason colonies that after-swarm produce little honey and sometimes die before winter.

If the colony only produces one or two after-swarms, the remaining virgin has a better chance of becoming the new queen. She emerges, matures for several days, and takes mating flights. If she mates successfully, laying begins roughly two to three weeks after emergence, and the colony slowly rebuilds. The delay in brood production leaves a gap in the worker population several weeks later.

For beekeepers, a colony that has cast several swarms should be assessed carefully. Check for a laying queen about three to four weeks after the prime swarm. If the colony has no queen, no eggs and a shrinking population, consider combining it with a stronger colony or giving it a mated queen. See queenlessness.

Recognizing and Preventing After-Swarms

Signs of after-swarming include piping, a cluster of bees much smaller than a prime swarm and evidence that the parent colony swarmed a few days earlier. Frequently, after-swarms leave in bursts on consecutive days during a spell of good weather.

Prevention begins with how you handle the colony after a prime swarm. Some practical options include:

  1. Reducing the parent colony to a single queen cell, selecting a well-formed one from the best-looking cells and removing the rest. This forecloses after-swarming but requires a careful search through every frame.
  2. Splitting the colony into nucleus colonies with one cell each, which spreads the bees and gives you additional colonies.
  3. Providing a mated queen to the parent colony, if you have one available, after removing all queen cells.

If you choose to keep one cell, leave a good one from the middle of the frame rather than the earliest or latest. Look for large, well-developed cells with a rough surface. Cell quality matters, and queens emerging from cells made during a swarm impulse are normally of good size, though not always. See supersedure for how that differs from emergency cells.

Catching After-Swarms

Beekeepers sometimes catch after-swarms in traps or by hiving a cluster. They are small and can be easy to shake into a box, but the odds of success are lower than with prime swarms. The queen may be a virgin, and she can easily fly off during hiving.

If you catch one, provide a small box or nucleus with frames of brood and food from a donor colony, and keep the colony warm and sheltered. Brood anchors bees and supplies the nurses and workers the colony needs. Check for a laying queen after three weeks. If none appears, combine with another colony or introduce a mated queen. See swarm catching.

It is often worth combining multiple casts to build one viable colony, but doing so requires care. Newspaper combination is a common method, and virgin queens must be managed so that only one survives.

Using After-Swarm Biology

Some beekeepers find after-swarm biology useful. A colony's willingness to build several queens can be exploited in queen rearing: in a swarm-impulse colony, high-quality cells are being fed generously, and mature cells can be harvested for mating nucs. See queenless starter nucs.

Others deliberately split colonies before swarming to avoid the problem. A split placed on the old stand with a queen cell and a portion of the brood satisfies the colony's drive to divide, and it avoids a long gap in brood production if the cell is well timed. See swarm season: prevention and management.

Beekeepers who raise queens often avoid selecting queens from lines that produce many after-swarms, because that trait can make colonies hard to manage. In areas with many feral colonies, after-swarms are a common source of new feral populations.

Practical Checklist for the Season

For beekeepers in swarm country, the following routine reduces losses.

  • Inspect weekly during peak swarm weeks, and note any capped cells.
  • If a prime swarm has already left, inspect the parent hive within a few days, before after-swarming starts.
  • Reduce cells to one or two good ones or split into nucs.
  • Keep notes on which colonies swarmed, when, and whether they after-swarmed.
  • Check for eggs three to four weeks after the prime swarm to confirm a laying queen.
  • Replace colonies that never recover with a purchased or raised queen.

Local regulation can apply to captured swarms and nuisance removals, so check with your extension office or state apiarist if you are unsure.

FAQ

How can I tell if a swarm has a virgin queen?

Swarms that appear a week or more after a prime swarm, or that are noticeably smaller, often have virgins, and piping from the parent hive before departure is another clue. Confirmation comes only by finding no eggs several weeks after hiving.

Do after-swarms always lead to colony loss?

No. Many parent colonies recover with a successfully mated virgin, but repeated after-swarms leave too few bees, and small casts often fail.

Should I cut out extra queen cells to stop after-swarms?

It can work if you leave one good cell and remove the rest, but you must search every frame carefully. Missing cells risks another swarm, and removing all cells risks queenlessness.

Keep learning

Browse all 500 guides →